Poll
27%
62%
12%
I see....double post......ignore my reply in the other thread then.
Let's see here........um.......Star Wars....
when it comes to fanboy geekdom, Star Wars can't be messed with. The movie has had a massive main-stream following for 30 years...........where as the other two flicks are some johnny come lately magic kiddie shit (HP) and Dungeons and Dragons knock off (LotR).....
Starwars is what even made the other two possible.
Ask Peter Jackson, he'll tell you so himself, or on the OT Starwars dvd's.
Again, as far as innovation and scope and scale: Starwars.
As far as movie quality (writing, acting, effects, music): Starwars/LOTR tie, and potter is last.
As far as overall fun to watch and likeability:
1. Starwars
2. LOTR
3. Potter
im a little fan boy who hates lord of the rings and loves star wars.
no not really, i dont mind lord of the rings, hell i dont like any of them that much but i voted star wars cuz i like all that sci-fi stuff.
lord of the rings was good but i liked starwars, or at least 4,5,6.
and as for harry potter, seen them all, never read any of the books, and meh dont really care for it all that much.
fanboy out.
Star Wars was like, "Hey, our movie worked. Let's see where we go from there." They formed a large following like that (with the original trilogy) and I respect that.
LOTR was pretentious, IMO. They were planning the success of it. I was waiting for one of the producers to point at me and say, "Hey, like it, or else!" The following these films were going to get was expected.
Harry Potter is kids stuff, hard to compare with the other two franchises.