Originally posted by golem370
Marv is a beast and a smart fighter I believe he could take Batman to the limit and then the other finish him.
Batman has a broader range of fighting styles; he also has the wit and resourcefulness of Macgyver- and he's very stealthy. Marv is strong but Batman is sly, and will probably take down the brute through other means. Hartigan? He's alright, but Bruce would out-detective his ass; what I mean by that is this: If it was a game of hide and seek, Batman would figure out the clues to Hartigan's location in an instant, sneak up from behind, and deliver the deadly Bat Touch. Dwight's the only one who I think has enough speed and range to kill Batman. But I still bet on The Dark Knight kicking some sneaky ass.
A Bloodlusted Batman? using all the killing arts??
Discount Marv & Hartigan, too slow.
Batman claims 3 kills in 3 seconds. Brings them in, close. drives fingers [L hand, R hand] through Dwight's, Hartigan's btain. Punches through Marv's neck. The tiger fist which gave Shiva an easy K.O. over Supergirl, will Tear Marv's head clean off his shoulders.
That's a pretty good fantasy scenario, but you've definitley underestimated these 3 Sin City characters. I'd be inclined to agree with you only none of these guys are going to sit around and let themselves be treated like Supergirl. Characters without her level of physical resistance get use to moving out of the way.