I think that really depends on WHY the critics like/hate it.
For example, Sex and the City 2 got really bad critics. I loved it, but I can see why some didn't. I mean, I mostly liked it because I loved seeing the characters again and because I missed the humor of the series. But the plot wasn't really that good. And I can totally see why someone who's not a fan of SATC would be bored.
I've just been obsessing over this play showing at my local theatre.
Seen it six times. Planning on more.
It IS awesome! The sad thing is that if I try to give you a quote from it, it's nearly impossible because it's one joke after another!
I can try, though.
Cop: *to Mrs. Schubert about her ring* Wow, that's some rock you got there, lady.
Mrs: Yes, that's the famous Schubert diamond. Of course, it comes with the Schubert curse.
Cop: ....What's the Schubert curse?
Mrs: Mr. Schubert.
~~~~~~~
And then of course there's just about anything Tony says.