Flavio:
I really like that you made the signature very different. I like the different shapes and a good use of transparency. The animation seemed a little choppy and took away from your sig rather than enhanced it.
Skeets:
Although you didn't think way outside of the box in my opinion, you met the critiera and I love the color scheme of the sig. It gave it depth and a magical overall feel.
Winner:
This was a hard duel to judge, for I really liked both entries, but in the end, it was Skeets that takes the win.
Great job both of you and thank you for letting me judge.