Immortal Hercules vs. Aquaman

Originally posted by galan7777777
yeah it would be a good fight, but i dont see AM being able to do enough damage (outside of telepathy) to herc that would put him down, and even with AM's telepathy im still not convinced that it would be enough..... i still say herc ftw

As I mentioned physically Aquaman loses, but honestly what defence does Hercules even have against telepathy?

Originally posted by King_Mungi
As I mentioned physically Aquaman loses, but honestly what defence does Hercules even have against telepathy?

Originally posted by galan7777777
well, im sure that his olympian body offers him some kind of defense, but im not sure how much....... if AM's telepathy could affect herc then he wins, if not herc beats him handily

Why would it? Hercules isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. Even Snowbird who is also a demi-god just like Hercules can receive telepathic messages.

Herc destroys Aquaman.

What about Aquaman's magic hand?

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Why would it? Hercules isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. Even Snowbird who is also a demi-god just like Hercules can receive telepathic messages.

Originally posted by galan7777777
because even though he isnt the smartest god he is still a god, and im sure he is more resistant to telepathic assults then a normal person

Right, but so what? White Martians are more resistent to telepathic assaults than normal people, but Aquaman messed one up pretty badly. I still don't see your point here galan.

Originally posted by batdude123
Right, but so what? White Martians are more resistent to telepathic assaults than normal people, but Aquaman messed one up pretty badly. I still don't see your point here galan.

Originally posted by galan7777777
ive already said that the only chance AM really has is telepathy, i was just arguing that herc is more resiliant to telepathic assults then a normal person would be

Okay, but that doesn't mean anything. Any "hero" has a more of a resistence to telepathy than a "normal" human being.

Originally posted by batdude123
Okay, but that doesn't mean anything. Any "hero" has a more of a resistence to telepathy than a "normal" human being.

Originally posted by galan7777777
agreed, but as an olympian im sure he is more resiliant then most would be..... that was all i was arguing

Kay..... Aquaman ftw.

Aquaman's full range of abilities gives him the win. He loses in a strictly physical confrontation, though he doesn't go down easy. He's beaten someone with the strength of Hercules before, and he's beaten Herc's fellow god, Triton.

Originally posted by galan7777777
because even though he isnt the smartest god he is still a god, and im sure he is more resistant to telepathic assults then a normal person

Demi-god, same as Snowbird. Have any proof he has any resistance to telepathy? As batdude mentioned White Martians have tp resistance yet he still caused one to have a seizure.

If its only on a physical basis, Hercules 10/10 in numerous laughers. With telepathy, I dont see any defense for Hercules. Aquaman wins. Hercules is a god and has been mind controlled before as has Thor by Moondragon. Theres no defense there.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Demi-god, same as Snowbird. Have any proof he has any resistance to telepathy? As batdude mentioned White Martians have tp resistance yet he still caused one to have a seizure.

true...

proof please that being a "god" grants you immunity or defense against telepathy...

maybe immunity from earthly diseases, yes, but tp, umm no, maybe, but not hercules, definitely...

Hercules takes the majority, pretty good fight though.

By countering with his own telepathic powers and magic hand?

Originally posted by Accel
The only time I saw him perform one, I recall he stopped a hurricane or tornado.

Created by the Beyonder.

Hes done it more than once. The last time was in the Ares mini by thunderclapping away mistical flames from Ajax, that wer buring him.

Originally posted by King_Mungi
Why would it? Hercules isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. Even Snowbird who is also a demi-god just like Hercules can receive telepathic messages.

What that has to do with having thelepatic defenses or not? Hercules isent stupid, hes a guy who often lets pride clouds jugdment but when calm he can chose to be rational like any other. Hes no Reed Richards, but who is?

Either you have a powerset/plot decive that includes telephatic defenses or you dont. Id call Hercules more telephatic -resistance- than defensive, wich gives AQ his best chances here. Otherwise hes going to sleep sooner or later.

At least he wont have to worry about drowning.

Some people said in the Super-man vs Hercules thread that Herc is more physhically fit, than Superman. (Or at least on par with him) I dunno about that. AM is very strong, strong enough to tussle with MM and the likes. He could cause lot's of dmg with his magical hand.. + his telepathy.. I dunno..

IMO Hercules should be some what phychially more fit than Thor as Herc doesn't have any other advantages, but that's only my opinion..

The entire match rests on whether or not Olympian Gods evolved from fish.