Proof that Lucas is a hack!

Started by NinthSith9 pages

Proof that Lucas is a hack!

Im sure some of you have seen this,but for those who havnt enjoy.

Pretty sad that a few highschool kids can put together a better choreographed duel then Lucas did for EP3....the ending to this duel is also better then Annakins death in Ep3

http://youtube.com/watch?v=_O_xaqWNd4w&mode=related&search=

the search option is your friend:

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=399007&highlight=title%3A%28awesome%29+forumid%3A38

Still it rocks... And like they said in your thread, PVS, better than the EPIII duel....

Now see this didnt impress me in the least. Sorry fellas. 😬

Re: Proof that Lucas is a hack!

Originally posted by NinthSith
Im sure some of you have seen this,but for those who havnt enjoy.

Pretty sad that a few highschool kids can put together a better choreographed duel then Lucas did for EP3....the ending to this duel is also better then Annakins death in Ep3

http://youtube.com/watch?v=_O_xaqWNd4w&mode=related&search=

Yeah, considering Lucas is such a big choreographer. 😬

Quit bitching about Lucas. No Lucas=No Star Wars, No Star Wars=No gay nerd lightsaber duels.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Now see this didnt impress me in the least. Sorry fellas. 😬

and the end of rots did? 😛

Actually yeah, I thought the final lightsaber duel was very cool. ✅

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Actually yeah, I thought the final lightsaber duel was very cool. ✅

😐

ah, cool as in 'look obi wan, look at me spinning my saber so heartily'

or something similar right? 😖hifty:

No sry, thats no where close to anything...
A Lightsaber dual alwalys has a story involved with it. These kids with nothing better to do may have made it look somewhat good.

In any lightsaber dual in SW, there was alwalys feeling and story behind it. I'd rather watch a saber dual with actual meaning to it, rather than just an action film....

Originally posted by queeq
Still it rocks... And like they said in your thread, PVS, better than the EPIII duel....

no it wasnt better. hayden and ewan were top notch.
if it was only filmed without all the quick cutting, that would have shown. ****ing lucas could **** up scrambled eggs.

Originally posted by JediRobin23
No sry, thats no where close to anything...
A Lightsaber dual alwalys has a story involved with it. These kids with nothing better to do may have made it look somewhat good.

In any lightsaber dual in SW, there was alwalys feeling and story behind it. I'd rather watch a saber dual with actual meaning to it, rather than just an action film....

you think most of the pt duels had actual tangible meaning? in the context of emotion and the choreography itself, not just in the result, or what was at stake...

Originally posted by PVS
no it wasnt better. hayden and ewan were top notch.
if it was only filmed without all the quick cutting, that would have shown. ****ing lucas could **** up scrambled eggs.

it could have been a little less ott though imo... 😬

Originally posted by pr1983
you think most of the pt duels had actual tangible meaning? in the context of emotion and the choreography itself, not just in the result, or what was at stake...

it could have been a little less ott though imo... 😬

WHAT movie did you watch???

Originally posted by JediRobin23
WHAT movie did you watch???

i was just asking, thats all... if you dont want to answer its perfectly fine...

I still hate that force hand pushing thing OB1 and Anakin do on Mustafar... that was....icky...

Originally posted by PVS
no it wasnt better. hayden and ewan were top notch.

Agreed. I and liked that force push.

Hayden had some great faces, especailly during the forcepush.

Originally posted by queeq
I still hate that force hand pushing thing OB1 and Anakin do on Mustafar... that was....icky...

the twirling competition followed by the force pushing contest? yeah...

(to Alliance's post) here we go....pokeypuke

Originally posted by pr1983
the twirling competition followed by the force pushing contest? yeah...

Yeah that whole bit... what BS...

no no no
the creme de le creme of carp was when they
did the lightsaber twirl. there is just no way to justify that....none