It really depends. I mean, sure he would be more powerful, but Sidious knows every single technique there is, if he has one Anakin doesn't know about, then he could beat him. Saying he is most powerful doesn't really matter if he hasn't got the knowledge to use it to it's full extent. For example, if this is ROTS Anakin given his full potential, I belive he would lose!
However, if this is an older Anakin, who has become so old that he cannot grow much more, than no doubt he would win...
Originally posted by kamikz
It really depends. I mean, sure he would be more powerful, but Sidious knows every single technique there is, if he has one Anakin doesn't know about, then he could beat him. Saying he is most powerful doesn't really matter if he hasn't got the knowledge to use it to it's full extent. For example, if this is ROTS Anakin given his full potential, I belive he would lose!
However, if this is an older Anakin, who has become so old that he cannot grow much more, than no doubt he would win...
You're missing the point. ROTS Anakin wasn't near his full potential. There is no grey area here. A full potential Anakin would win period.
'Who cares, potential implies that he's had all this.'
Not really. He can still be at his full potential in the force but he still might not have had the perfect quality of training, knowledge of the force or proper experience.
For example, you can argue that Mace Windu reached his full potential by ROTS. This doesn't mean that he might not have ever gotten any more powerful. If he, say had better knowledge of the force (force blocking for example), way more battle experience and training in the dark side, he would surely be more powerful, correct?
Originally posted by superstonerlet put this another way ...Darth Revan has more experience than DE sidious will ever have RIght but we all know that sids wpould WTFpwn him rather easily
a 30 mega ton nuke is all power but a marine sniper who's been doing his job the best for twenty years has exp,knolwedg,training ...now who wins(D.A)
Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Ugh how so Rex? A Full potential Anakin=full potential Luke. That means they're equal, that means neither one is stronger than the other.
Luke is incredibly powerful, but I still think F-P Anakin would be the stronger. Luke's mother was not Force sensitive, which may detract from it, and Luke is not the Chosen One, as well.
@ Jen
Does it really matter? I assume from reading 'Full potential' that he is at the height of his power and has had the necessary training to reach it. I have always assumed as such, and will rule it as such.
@ Superstoner
Please do not bring Supershadow into this.