Count Dooku and ROTS Obi Wan versus Anakin Skyalker (ROTS)

Anakin didn't use his anger on Dooku.

He utilised the same frame of mind Obi-Wan did in his final duel with Darth Maul.

He used Fury.

In other words, It was completely controlled agression, tapped into one powerful fuel source. Not out of control at all.

He never once used anger. It the novel it describes him being bascially clear minded as possible, and all he had to do to win, was dicide.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Fury is a synonym of anger and no one ever said anger was uncontrolled rage. So in essence I am right.

Fury, according to Martial Artists, the experts on combat, Is controlled anger, not uncontrolled, as you are putting it, so in essence you are wrong, sir.

Since when does anger = unclead minded?

Dosen't matter does it? He wasen't angry.

Originally posted by Darth Sexiest
Dosen't matter does it? He wasen't angry.

Anakin did use his anger. You think Palpatine doesn't fight with anger? He simply can control it

And no one said this was only sabers. So, if this was a full-fight with The Force and sabers, Anakin will by no means beat Dooku in a short time. Raw Force power is useless against experienced Force power. And I'm not just talking about lightning. I'm pretty sure Dooku knows more about The Force and powers with it than Anakin does at this point.

Anakin goes down.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Fury is a synonym of anger and no one ever said anger was uncontrolled rage. So in essence I am right.

Since when does anger = unclead minded?

I'm not the one who said he was angry, cause he was not angry at all. The novel makes this as clear as his mind was. Sorry to tell you.

Originally posted by Nikkolas
Anakin did use his anger. You think Palpatine doesn't fight with anger? He simply can control it

And no one said this was only sabers. So, if this was a full-fight with The Force and sabers, Anakin will by no means beat Dooku in a short time. Raw Force power is useless against experienced Force power. And I'm not just talking about lightning. I'm pretty sure Dooku knows more about The Force and powers with it than Anakin does at this point.

Anakin goes down.

Proof? Can you prove he used anger to kill dooku? I can prove that he didn't. Until you see what dooku can do, you have no choice but to speculate. You don't know what Anakin or Dooku could truely do. And if Dooku really was that good, he would have used the force on him in the movie. It wasn't like palpatine said, "OK guys, you can fight now, but only sabers...no force powers." No, f*ck that. In a fight, you do everything you can, if not, and you die as a result, you deserve it cause you're not as good as you thought ir as in control as you thought.

Individually, Anakin could own both, as he proved with Dooku's trick ass. But together, he loses. The onslaught would be too relentless from both combatants for him to do any real damage. He might mortally would one while the other attacks him from the back. Anakin has no chance at a divide and conquer.

Also, on a side note, if Anakin was in the mind state he was when fighting Kenobi, he would mos def lose. THAT"S rage and not thinking clearly. But at the time of the ROTS Anakin/Dooku fight, Anakin did not use one ounce of anger, rage, pissed offedness, hate, fear, or...anything synonymous with anger.

Also, yes Palps does fight with anger, he's a sith, Anakin was a Jedi...big difference. But even later as mech vader, he didnt use his anger near as much, rather he had superb control over it.

I'm not the one who said he was angry, cause he was not angry at all. The novel makes this as clear as his mind was. Sorry to tell you.

Originally posted by darthsith19
The duo for sure. Kenobi alone did this in ROTS and even though it was only because Anakin f*cked up, still, even if he hadn't their close. Meanwhile Dooku is even closer to Anakin, IMO if Anakin hadn';t used his anger on Dooku in ROTS Dooku might have beaten him. So alone eitehr one of the duo is close to Anakin so I see no reason why the 2 combined wouldn't beat him comfortably.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Wrong, after Dooku tauneted Anakin and said he didn't use his anger and fear Anakin went beserk on Dooku.

So yes you DID say he was angry, or used his anger...I wasnt implying that you said I said it. I was just clarifying because i figured youwere answering me...miscommunication...👆

I was answering you. You said he doesn't use his anger, but he does. He uses it only after Dooku taunts him, which is what I was trying to say in the second quote of mine that you posted.

but he DID NOT use anger...at ALL. Its not even up for debate...thats been stated NUMEROUS times. There is no point to argue it..its already been proven...

Sigh...man you are bias.

"[Dooku] understood how Skywalker was getting stronger... He was half-Sith already and he didn't even know it. And even now, he was holding himself back. ...Dooku could feel how Skywalker kept his fury banked behind walls of will."

"Then, Sidious for some reason, decided to intervene...'rage is your weapon. Strike now, strike. kill him.'"

"And all for nothing because a nuclear flame has consumed Anakin Skywalker's Jedi restraint and fear becomes fury without effort... But for Anakin, in the fight there is only terror and rage... But Palpatine's words 'rage is your weapon' had given Anakin permission to unseal the shielding around his furnace-heart... His firewalls had opened so that the terror and the rage are out there. In the fight instead of in his head."

Your arguments are pitiful next to facts. Anakin used the dark side to beat Dooku. Accept it.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
But at the time of the ROTS Anakin/Dooku fight, Anakin did not use one ounce of anger, rage, pissed offedness, hate, fear, or...anything synonymous with anger.

Since I'm not going to bother to read this entire debate (as it's completely nothing but unsupported bullshit), I'm going to post one passage from the Revenge of the Sith novelization:

"A starburst of clarity blossoms within Anakin Skywalker's mind, when he says to himself Oh. I get it, now and discovers that the fear within his heart can be a weapon, too. "

There's also about oh say, eight or so references to Anakin using his anger, his rage, and such as a weapon. This differs from how he dueled Kenobi in the way that he was attacking with blind rage, not thinking clearly, not "using his fear" to conquer. His rage conquered him.

"And even now, he was holding himself back; even now, as he landed at Dooku's flank and rained blows upon the Sith Lord's defenses, even as he drove Dooku backward step after step, Dooku could feel how Skywalker kept his fury banked behind walls of will: walls that were hardened by some uncontrollable dread. "

The one holding himself back is Anakin.

"in the fight instead of in his head, and Anakin's mind is clear as a crystal bell.
In that pristine clarity, there is only one thing he must do.
Decide.
So he does.
He decides to win."

Reading that meant to me that, yes he had rage in there, but was holding it back and not using it...if it was a misuderstanding on my part, i apologize. But when i think of using fear and anger, i think of his fight with OB1. That and Dooku said that he didnt use them...so i figured he didnt use them at all...until he had already beated him and cut off his head. SO in essence, thats the same as when Mace uses Vaapad, correct?

And its not being bias at all...the fact is that he beat Dooku, thats whats important part, not so much how he did it. But i was trying to convey the difference between their fight, and the fight with OB1....but like I said, if i misunderstood...my bad...I can admit it...thats what a man does...

Yes, yes, we've been over he beat Dooku. Hooray. The fact is, this is not Anakin v. Dooku. This is Dooku and Obi-Wan vs. Anakin. A Dooku and Obi-Wan who have been given time to practice techniques as a team, no less. So...if Dooku uses The Force and Obi-Wan uses sabers, they could win. Or any other number of ways. Not a pwn. A win.

as ive said plenty of times...i never once said that Anakin could win this...i was saying that if he used his rage in this fight(which sparked the whole rage vs Dooku sub-topic) he would lose even quicker. Thats all.

Ah. Righto. Sorry.

Dooku/Obi win. Yay.

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
Reading that meant to me that, yes he had rage in there, but was holding it back and not using it...

Except that was before Dooku had taunted him, once Dooku did taunt him, the quotes provided by Nikkolas and myself come into play. So, yes: he did use his anger, his fear, his emotions against Dooku to win.

And the second quote you provided came long after the first quote. It comes immediately after the quote I provided, where he is using his emotions as weapons.

ok the way you posted it beofre (the mega post) i just misinturrepted it. My bad.

Originally posted by Nikkolas
Ah. Righto. Sorry.

Dooku/Obi win. Yay.