Rate the Comic Signature

Started by DigiMark007143 pages

Rate the Comic Signature

New "Rating Rules"

1. Your post must have a 1-10 rating. Decimals are acceptable.

2. No posts of "rated" (or the "rated" smiley). If you have already rated someone's signature, wait until someone else joins in to post yours.

3. Brief commentary on the rating is acceptable and encouraged.

4. It's not personal if someone thinks yours is a 4 (or something similar). Some people judge on varying criteria, and many have different standards of what is good and bad. If you can't accept criticism, stay out.

5. Have fun, stay respectful.

....

This wasn't getting any traffic in the movie forum and was stagnating with many of the same people. I wanted to make the new rules, so making an entirely new thread made sense.

...that's all. Enjoy. 🙂

10/10.

droolio 6-7/10

i'm sorry i don't get how this works so do i rate nino's sig or do i rate bigbrans sig?

Originally posted by invisiblewoman
i'm sorry i don't get how this works so do i rate nino's sig or do i rate bigbrans sig?

You rate the one immediately above you.

8.5 btw 👆

Originally posted by DigiMark007
You rate the one immediately above you.

8.5 btw 👆

aha.... sorry to mess up the chain this rating is for nino

8/10

Digi - 8/10
IW - 7/10

Now we are back on track 🙂

BW 8/10...very nice👆

7/10

I dig it.

Madd funny...7/10

8.5/10

cool 7/10

7/10... On Roquess, you know what it is...

This was my old one.

It's friggin hand drawn by jinzin the cyber-ninja! I think it's bloody awesome. Best ever made.

8/10

9.5/10

8/10. That's a very intense looking Surfer.

7.8/10

Thing/Hulk beatdowns are teh awesome

6.5/10

I would have given it more if it wasn't for the "For one to be remembered one must do something of greatness. For good or evil. Greatness must be prevalent though , always prevalent." which to me is a bit preachy (though quite a nice message).

Without that, it would have been closer to 7.5 or 8/10.

Sorry, somebody else would have probably given you a higher rating!

7/10

Kind of grainy, but it reminds me of Guenhwyvar though so I like it.