you smell funny/compass scene?

That's what I think too, Lovethemtigers, is that Jack thought he was putting Will in a safe place with his dad for the time being. He didn't plan on leaving him on there forever I don't think. Jack's pretty protective of Will even though he doesn't like him. Nothing bad's happening to Will on his watch.

Anyone notice Jack's face when Norrington says 'You actually believe him?" It's like Jack is trying to say "Please believe me. I loo like a sad puppy and I love you Lizzie!" haha It really is a pleading look though.

yep that's the look I refered to earlier on this same thread....about the look he gives Lizzie just after norrie says "you don't actually believe him, do you?"

haha sorry I guess I didn't see it. I just watched the clip and saw it and thought I'd point it out. hehe

This is an early post of mine, I just wanted to repeat it. Perhaps no one heard me. It was refering to the widowed before the marrage theory.

Facinating about the whole widowed thing. I do think that Elizabeth was missing Jack, but mostly the adventure that he always dragged her into. I do think she loved him ever since he left, but she didn't realize it till he came BACK into her life in Tortuga. All the feelings were buried inside, and she was used to surpressing her true feelings.

She just accepted that Jack would never come back and she'd just have to marry Will and have a normal life. She didn't count on Jack being pushed back into her life, with Beckett and all, and then she ran into him in Tortuga. That was when she realized that she really did love him, but she kept it inside and forced herself to think that he'd just leave her again and she'd have to go back to Will.

You know that moment when he gave her the compass, I know she knew it was a compass but that look she had on her face. Didn't it look like she thought he was purposing to her? Lol, she's all speachless and it looks like she's convincing herself that it's just a compass.

Then she says, "Ohhh, Jack." Like she's deciding saying yes or no but she still has doubts whether it's a compass or not. Follow me? And with Jack saying all those things about what you want most in the world, it really does sound like he's proposing.

And you know whats really funny When Jack says "It points to the thing you want most in the world" and looks at her, Liz says "Ohh Jack" as if she noticed what was going on with him. She then asks him "are you telling the truth?" as if she is asking him do you really want me? is it me that you really want? And then Jack says every word love. ok it sounded retarded 😕 😄

Lmfao, I know. It's perfect

I really think that was the backdrop of the scene, they foreshadowed what Jack might do later on, fall inlove with Lizzie and propose to her...

Yeah, I hope that's what it meant...

I dont know if anyone said this, (i havent read it all sorry lol)

but when she said "All I want is to find will" he made a face like "why do you want him??" or "bah!" lol sumthing! then it looked like he realized she could use that to find the chest...

Is that obvious?

Im slow hehe

Yeah, he cocks his head and makes a sound. I always thought of it as "yeah, yeah, I know, duh." And then he gets his idea. Remember he is trying to entice her to use the compass and have it find the chest. All the flirting is on the unconscious level. But it is funny, like he gets easily tired of Will as a subject.