book 7 title

Spoiler:
no I reckon voldie used the death of harry's parents to cement the spell. slughorn said that living creatures didn't make good horcruxes, but maybe voldie wants to be clever, putting it in the one place he knows no one would ever bring themself to destroy. SO, in order to destroy voldie, harry has to kill himself...

Originally posted by Phoenix

Spoiler:
no I reckon voldie used the death of harry's parents to cement the spell. slughorn said that living creatures didn't make good horcruxes, but maybe voldie wants to be clever, putting it in the one place he knows no one would ever bring themself to destroy. SO, in order to destroy voldie, harry has to kill himself...

Harry?no no no no no ...........I don't want to believe that.it could be true but i won't believe it.its a bit far fetched ................or not.but Harry?no no no no no no no ...............that would be horrible , to have to destroy Harry to destroy the horcrux .

Originally posted by Hermione202
Harry?no no no no no ...........I don't want to believe that.it could be true but i won't believe it.its a bit far fetched ................or not.but Harry?no no no no no no no ...............that would be horrible , to have to destroy Harry to destroy the horcrux .

Oh, I've just had a thought. Remeber in OotP, when Harry and co/ were clearing out a cabinet...didn't they find an old locket that they couldn't open in there? Regulus must have put it in 12 Grimmauld Place! Maybe lol...

Remember the prophecy, neither can live while the other survives. ONE of them kills the OTHER. So Harry cannot kill himself that way. And wasn't it Slughorn who said that creatures with life still in them don't exactly make good horcruxes?

Originally posted by DarkCanadian
Remember the prophecy, neither can live while the other survives. ONE of them kills the OTHER. So Harry cannot kill himself that way. And wasn't it Slughorn who said that creatures with life still in them don't exactly make good horcruxes?

I was thinking about that

Originally posted by TheSun
Oh, I've just had a thought. Remeber in OotP, when Harry and co/ were clearing out a cabinet...didn't they find an old locket that they couldn't open in there? Regulus must have put it in 12 Grimmauld Place! Maybe lol...

Originally posted by Elessea
That makes a lot of sense...It could very well be *goes to re-read that part of OotP*

I agree

Originally posted by Hermione202
I agree

Originally posted by TheSun
Wahey! For once I'm not shot down in flames and accused of inciting a riot!

well.......................It does make sense and you did not accuse anyone. Sometimes you're quite a nice an reasonable person.AT other times.......well.................we all make mistakes..................right?

I think its regalus too

Yeah, its either Reglus or a new character, because 'Black' and 'Bones' are the only 'B' surnames that are main characters.

It could be someone 'Bones', since she was killed quite recently and because it was mentioned it has to be important.

i dunno

I am half thinking it was Regulus but... How would he be able to do it alone? Wouldn't he need help drinking it like Dumbledore? I think R.A.B. might be three people, but the fact that it might be at Black's house is high and I agree with that. And Harry being one of the horcrux... no. Because Harry has to destroy all of them before he could defeat Voldemort, which means he will have to kill himself before killing him.... which I don't really thinks possible.

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I am half thinking it was Regulus but... How would he be able to do it alone? Wouldn't he need help drinking it like Dumbledore? I think R.A.B. might be three people, but the fact that it might be at Black's house is high and I agree with that. And Harry being one of the horcrux... no. Because Harry has to destroy all of them before he could defeat Voldemort, which means he will have to kill himself before killing him.... which I don't really thinks possible.

hahahaha

that last part about Harry killing himself was funny! and no , i don't think thats possible

I have two different theories, that may prove that Dumbledore may come back to life. First remember in OOTP how the Time Turners were destroyed, what if someone had a spare somewhere and they use it to bring back Dumbleore. Another theory is about the horcruxes. Slughorn was saying that you need to split your soul or something like that. And Voldemort killed to make his horcruxes stronger. What if their is something similar to that without the killing, then Dumbledore could come back. It sounds wild, but those could be possibilities. I'm sure Dumbledore isn't gone forever.

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I am half thinking it was Regulus but... How would he be able to do it alone? Wouldn't he need help drinking it like Dumbledore? I think R.A.B. might be three people, but the fact that it might be at Black's house is high and I agree with that. And Harry being one of the horcrux... no. Because Harry has to destroy all of them before he could defeat Voldemort, which means he will have to kill himself before killing him.... which I don't really thinks possible.

yes you are!

Originally posted by Saratn
I have two different theories, that may prove that Dumbledore may come back to life. First remember in OOTP how the Time Turners were destroyed, what if someone had a spare somewhere and they use it to bring back Dumbleore. Another theory is about the horcruxes. Slughorn was saying that you need to split your soul or something like that. And Voldemort killed to make his horcruxes stronger. What if their is something similar to that without the killing, then Dumbledore could come back. It sounds wild, but those could be possibilities. I'm sure Dumbledore isn't gone forever.