Originally posted by DanZeke25
Harry is not a Horcrux. You have to do a spell to transfer you soul, and the only spell Voldemort did was Avada Kedavra. Thats is not the spell to transfer your soul. Why would it be?
How do you know? We've never had the full death scene, so you have no idea what happened
Originally posted by Phoenix
How do you know? We've never had the full death scene, so you have no idea what happened
as i said before, the curse rebounded and hit Voldemort. How oculd Voldemort perform the spell to make Harry a horcrux if he doesnt have a body?
the only possible way is...
remeber in the interview, someone asked JKR if anybody else was present in Godric's Hollow that night? SHe said no comment. So the only way Harry could be a Horcrux is if the other person who was there(assuming he's with Voldemort) performed the spell to make harry a Horcrux. But Voldemort wouldnt tell naybody about his Horcruxes, so thats not likely.
well i said something about this on another thread... you know how voldie wanted somethign from each founder. where JK sed that there was a connection between godric's hollow and godric griffindor. so what if he used one of harry's parents death as what would split his soul to make the horcrux, and the horcrux was somethign that he found in godrics hollow that was griffindors? cuz dd did say that he hadnt yet made the first one until he went to godrics hollow to find harry.
That makes sense. Also another reason to thin Harry might be the horcrux is that the sorting hat had such a hard time placing Harry and thought about placing him in Slytherin. If he had two souls within him to some degree, the sorting hat would be confused.
It also makes sense that Voldemort would try to get the best of the prophecy by being extra sneaky and making Harry a Horcrux instead of killing him.
I don't see why Voldmort needs another person to preform the spell. He was able to make all the other horcruxes alone, why not this one?
i think R.A.B is not regulus , because dumbledore and harry struggled to escape the hiding place of the horcrux and it doesnt say in any of the books that regulus was a skilled wizard
i think tht R.A.B is either an old wizard or the initials of the actual hiding place of the horcrux or maybe voldemort had already used tht horcruz ...last bit is unlikely but ey i thought i'd mention it
Originally posted by div
i think R.A.B is not regulus , because dumbledore and harry struggled to escape the hiding place of the horcrux and it doesnt say in any of the books that regulus was a skilled wizard
i think tht R.A.B is either an old wizard or the initials of the actual hiding place of the horcrux or maybe voldemort had already used tht horcruz ...last bit is unlikely but ey i thought i'd mention it
Ok, lets just say for the sake of argument that Harry was a horcrux...perhaps Voldemort already used the Horcrux he put in harry at the end of GOF. The ritual voldy went through, "brought him back to life." So to speak. That would make one less horcrux that Harry would have to destroy. Voldemort used it first because living beings dont make good horcruxes.
i can see your point but i dont think thats y voldemort needed harrys blood because it had less to do with bringing him bck to life and more to do with returning his physical form....also if u remember that voldys power go transferred to harry when he attempted to curse him so maybe he needed the blood to return his power
Do you think that maybe Dumbledore was at Godric's Hollow the night VOldemort tried to kill Harry? BEcause when he drank that potion, maybe he was ahving a flashback. Because he did say "No. Dont kill them." "Dont hurt them." "Its my fault.!" "I did wrong." "KILL ME"
And o wonder how every wizard would know about it so fast if no one was there to witness it?
I have a question...
Why would Voldemort make Harry a Horcrux? Obviously, the answer would be: Harry would have to kill himself, therefore making it impossible to kill Voldemort, unless they somehow died at the same time. This, however, wouldn't make sense. Harry would have to kill himself, and then the part of the soul in Voldemort would have to be killed.
Now, again, why would Voldemort make Harry a horcrux? Making Harry a Horcrux would mean two things:
1) Voldemort would not be able to kill Harry. This is totally contradicting what Voldemort set out to do, i.e. kill Harry.
and
2) Harry would not be able to kill Voldemort. Now, this is all good for Voldie, and would make sense, but when would he be able to turn Harry into a horcrux? Obviously, it wasn't the night when he tried to kill Harry, because why would he kill Harry if he had made him a horcrux? And, also obviously, it wasn't after he attacked Harry, for he had already 'died' and become a 'spirit.'
So, in turn, making Harry a horcrux would prove to hinder Voldemort--albeit, as well as Harry--and also prove to be impossible, as I said...
UNLESS!
Unless... do you remember when Voldemort regained his body? Wormtail drew blood from Harry. Could this have made Harry a horcrux? It is possible, but once again improbable. Soon after Voldemort regains his body, he duels with Harry, obviously hoping to kill him. Why would he do this? He would be making an unneccessary move, i.e. destroying a part of his soul when killing Harry.
There is one more thing that prevents me to believe that Harry is a horcrux. Throughout the books, Voldemort has tried--on numerous occasions--to kill Harry.
In the first book as Quirrel.
In the second book with the Basilisk.
In the fourth book by dueling with him.
And in the fifth book, by once again dueling with him. (If you call him sending death curses at Harry, who didn't do much back, a duel.)
Killing Harry would destroy the part of Voldie's soul within him, if Harry was a Horcrux. If this was the case, why would Voldemort constantly be trying to kill Harry?
There, I rest my case... for Today. My head hurts.
I dont remeber when Dumbledore said you had to destroy the Horcruxes first before you kill Voldemort. I thought he just said that it would be easier, because if u killed Voldemort first, and then went looking for the Horcruxes, you probaly wouldnt find them in time and VOldemort would come back. So if Harry is a horcrux(which he is not) couldnt Harry kill Voldemort and then kill himself? Surely Voldemort wouldnt be able to come back within a matter of seconds?
Harry isnt a Horcrux anyway. I think its a stupid idea.