Luke (NJO) vs. Darth Revan and DE Palpatine

Started by Darth Sexy2 pages

I think Palpatine is very interesting as he is THE most brilliant character in the SW universe.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
I think Palpatine is very interesting as he is THE most brilliant character in the SW universe.

I would have to agree 100% with this statement.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
I think Palpatine is very interesting as he is THE most brilliant character in the SW universe.

That would depend on your definition of brilliance. Tactical abilities... hells no (though he ain't that bad.) Brilliant in sciences/engineering well we don't know how brilliant he is there. Politically brilliant, again I would rate this as being more the stupidity of his contemporaries, but I say he was decent here 😛

The MOST interesting character would have to be Darth Vader (armoured Vader)

Originally posted by Prodigal Knight
You're a Revan hater, aren't you ESB?

sure am,

Originally posted by zephiel7
That would depend on your definition of brilliance. Tactical abilities... hells no (though he ain't that bad.) Brilliant in sciences/engineering well we don't know how brilliant he is there. Politically brilliant, again I would rate this as being more the stupidity of his contemporaries, but I say he was decent here 😛

The MOST interesting character would have to be Darth Vader (armoured Vader)

Oh, please Zephiel. Get off your KotoR high horse. Palpatine was brilliant. His achievements and accomplishments, by far outstrip any other Sith Lord (including - guess who? - Revan). His schemes and plans were without peer, as was his patience, and his power is also peerless as well - for a Sith Lord.

Nobody is arguing Palpatine's place in history is #1. But I WILL argue that in terms of brilliance, knowledge, and intelligence, Revan is #2.

Originally posted by Escape81
Oh, please Zephiel. Get off your KotoR high horse. Palpatine was brilliant. His achievements and accomplishments, by [B]far outstrip any other Sith Lord (including - guess who? - Revan). His schemes and plans were without peer, as was his patience, and his power is also peerless as well - for a Sith Lord. [/B]

You are entitled to your opinion.

I say that his political success came from the stupidity of his contemporaries (ie, Jar Jar.) He is a cliched villain, too much so.

He was a powerful Sith Lord though... but power hardly makes one intersting. In conclusion I would just think of him as another cliched evil doer...except within the Star Wars universe.

Vader had far more depth as a villain.