Originally posted by Prodigal Knight
Hey I put in the B Class because you haven't proven who you bested and whatsoever. I am not sure if you are better than Darthsith19. However, Kadesh has proven himself already.
He has? I've seen better debating in the local unemployment office than I've seen from some of you guys here in the past few days.
Originally posted by Darth Sexywell i certainly have seen mentally retarded people debate better than some one who likes to assume superiority and act like hes the king of the world.
He has? I've seen better debating in the local unemployment office than I've seen from some of you guys here in the past few days.
That's enough. This has turned into Ego-Fest '06. It is impossible to rank "the best debators". What is the criteria? Who's won the most debates?
How can you tell who has won, unless the other concedes, and even then you still may be wrong.
I'd consider Nai and Janus better "debators" than myself, and they certainly possess much more knowledge of Star Wars and other fictional areas (as well as real world areas) than I do - but that doesn't mean that I have never proven them wrong (see the Dooku > Sidious issue or the Dooku > Anakin issue).
I can vouch for Darth Sexy. He has a limited (though, in some areas, his knowledge exceeds mine by quite a bit) knowledge of Star Wars, and you can catch him in times where he makes no sense and misconstrues one's argument. But when you catch him on a good day, and he's got his head in the game, he's very, very good.
At the same time, San'Doria seems to be a pretty good debator himself, but some of his claims are completely ridiculous and without basis - and he has shown moments of extreme egotism himself.
Best just let the topic die.
Yea, I've not read the DE series, so my knowledge is limited, but from what I've heard from other people on here, DE Sidious tools all of them. In this case, I don't think Sid's lightning would be on a level where anyone could block it with a saber, so Vader eats it hard before it starts. Dooku might be arrogant enough to try to compete with im in the force but gets pwned in mere seconds, and Maul...c'mon, he stands less of a chance than the other two.
If it came to saber battle, they still stand no chance, even together. If Sidious can really move to fast to see then i don't see how its a contest. If Vader could even hit him, it might stall Sids long enough for one the faster ones to make an effort, but with no avail.
I see no way for Sidious to lose here. Unless one of them pulls a Han Solo and shoots him in the back from a far, then they all die in under 4 minutes.
Originally posted by Escape81i cant deny that.
That's enough. This has turned into Ego-Fest '06. It is impossible to rank "the best debators". What is the criteria? Who's won the most debates?How can you tell who has won, unless the other concedes, and even then you still may be wrong.
I'd consider Nai and Janus better "debators" than myself, and they certainly possess much more knowledge of Star Wars and other fictional areas (as well as real world areas) than I do - but that doesn't mean that I have never proven them wrong (see the Dooku > Sidious issue or the Dooku > Anakin issue).
I can vouch for Darth Sexy. He has a limited (though, in some areas, his knowledge exceeds mine by quite a bit) knowledge of Star Wars, and you can catch him in times where he makes no sense and misconstrues one's argument. But when you catch him on a good day, and he's got his head in the game, he's very, very good.
At the same time, San'Doria seems to be a pretty good debator himself, but some of his claims are completely ridiculous and without basis - and he has shown moments of extreme egotism himself.
Best just let the topic die.
Anyways if this is DE sidious he would be smart enugh to fool the trio, and no he wouldnt kill them, he would break them as he broke luke and make them do his dirty work, Its a fact since sidious prefers to have allies with the same ambition to wreck the republic apart.
ive read part of palpatine on DESB, It said he is believed to have mastered all forms of the dark side, doesnt mean he did ya know, cuz his powers appears on the stat page