John Carpenter's Thing vs. Ridley Scott's Alien

Started by LORDSIDIOUS012 pages
LORDSIDIOUS01 The BatLord of the Jedi

Loved both films but as a whole, Alien should win

dave_kodak Party Dave

I don't mean to be bitchy, but how do you think an alien could win? other then bleeding on the thing.

I'm a fan of both and i have seen all the alien movies at least 4 times each.
and I just cant see it beating the thing, Unless there is more then one.

LifeInSepia nuff sed

Originally posted by dave_kodak
I don't mean to be bitchy, but how do you think an alien could win? other then bleeding on the thing.

I'm a fan of both and i have seen all the alien movies at least 4 times each.
and I just cant see it beating the thing, Unless there is more then one.

then thing would just consume alien via the blood. nuff sed.

Smasandian Smell the Ashes

But the blood is acid. Can the Thing infect acid? Nothing in the movies showcased that.

So, The Thing would try to do whatever it does, but you all say blood is the reason, but the Alien doesnt have blood while dogs, and humans do.

So, by the movies, the Alien would win because of that reason.

But overall, you cant really say who would win because well, nothing in the movie suggest that the Thing could become the alien. The reason being acid for blood.