Wolverine Vs Sabertooth

Started by jinzin8 pages

Originally posted by capt it up
he fails? really last I check logan has kciked the shit out of sabertooth many times.

please prove sabertooth has more wins because I am almost 100% positive that he does not.

Not a majority of the time...

well he does.
sabretooth win record:
pwned logan in wolverine 10
pwned logan in classic x-men 10
had a superior showing in uncanny 212
had logan dead to rights in wolverine 42 teech at logan's jugular
had logan beat in wolverine 46
was pwning logan in hand to hand in wolverine 91
curbed logan in wolverine 126
beat logan in wolverine 166
dropped logan in wolverine vol II 19
proved himself superior to logan in wolverine vol II 50
proved himself superior again at the end of 50 continued into 51.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
He also stated that he was Wolverine's father and apparently spent years pretending to be a imbecile. They guy is a sly bastard.

And really just how often has Sabretooth said he was going to kill Wolverine? Or even that he was trying to kill Wolverine? He has said that no one but him will kill Wolverine... but he seems more concerned with torturing Wolverine and messing with his head then with actually killing him.

There relationship is like Denzel Washington character in the movie Fallen and the Fallen Angel serial killer; it could have killed him any time... but that was no fun so it decided to ruin his life and **** with him.

co-signed...

and speaking of balls out sabretooth....

yeah.. hmmmm

he was getting there in uncanny when he dropped psylocke.. but even then it was stated later that he wasn't going for the kill on bets..
sabretooth in the red zone he was pretty furious and he's got the feats to prove it.

other than that.. nothing really comes to mind.

maybe AOA when he fought holocaust.

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Sabretooth is Wolverine's Venom. Everything Wolverine is, Sabretooth is too... only more so. Its not even up for debate. Wolverine holds his own because of his tenacity, never say die attitude and plot devices. They aren't equals and Wolverine isn't superior.
they both have a healing factor and good fighting abilities. but sab is faster stronger and heals faster as well.

plus he's hella more durable.. just look at wolverine vol II 51...

wolverine comes out of the plane wreck a damn near walking skeleton.. all that happened to sabretooth was his hair getting burnt off. 😬

Yeah, Sabretooth wins. And he's usually toying with Wolverine, as stated.

How many times have we seen Sabretooth knock wolverine out, only to have Wolverine wake up later going "Shit..."

If Sabretooth had wanted to, he could have just killed him while he was out. 😐.

Originally posted by jinzin
Not a majority of the time...well he does.
No he does not. Your entire argument is that Sabretooth has more OFF PANEL victories. On panel Wolverine obviously has more victories.
Originally posted by jinzin
pwned logan in wolverine 10
True, but Wolverine pwned Creed in their first ever fight.
Originally posted by jinzin
pwned logan in classic x-men 10
Via sneak attack.
Originally posted by jinzin
had a superior showing in uncanny 212
Oh, that fight where Wolverine had Creed pinned and helpless by the end of the fight? Please.
Originally posted by jinzin
had logan dead to rights in wolverine 42 teech at logan's jugular
Oh yeah, via sneak attack AGAIN, while Wolverine was falling out of a helicopter and carrying on a conversation with Elsie Dee while not even engaged in a fight. Creed didn't do jack shit in that issue to prove any supposed "superiority." I suppose Wolverine proved his "superiority" when he cut off Creed's hand while the guy was fighting Black Panther? That seems fair to me.
Originally posted by jinzin
had logan beat in wolverine 46
Are you high? Wolverine had just got done fighting a HANDICAP fight against Tooth and Lady D. Creed had 1 hand around Wolverine's neck and you call that a win? Bullshit. Not a fiar fight, therefor no winner. Even if it was acceptable Creed has no win. Fight is interupted.
Originally posted by jinzin
was pwning logan in hand to hand in wolverine 91
You mean # 90. And was only pwning because Wolverine was holding back in the fight as we have gone over before. Wolverine won that fight.
Originally posted by jinzin
curbed logan in wolverine 126
Due to suprise power-up # 1.
Originally posted by jinzin
beat logan in wolverine 166
Creed hadn't beaten anyone as we have already gone over. He had an advantage in the fight due to suprise power-up # 2
Originally posted by jinzin
dropped logan in wolverine vol II 19
True.
Originally posted by jinzin
proved himself superior to logan in wolverine vol II 50
No such thing happened. Wolverine landed more hits than Creed. Fight ends in double KO. Draw.
Originally posted by jinzin
proved himself superior again at the end of 50 continued into 51.
50 was a draw with a double KO. In 51 Wolverine has big advantage over Creed while fighting in the jet. Creed was helpless until the plane crashed, freeing him from Wolverine's strangle hold. On the ground they were locked in stalemate until Storm breaks up the fight.

Sorry to say this since I usually hold a lot of respect for your opinion, but you are being blatantly untruthful a lot in this thread.

Originally posted by riceroost
No he does not. Your entire argument is that Sabretooth has more OFF PANEL victories. On panel Wolverine obviously has more victories.

No.. PART of my reasoning for why I think sabretooth is logan's superior is based in the fact that Sabretooth is stated over and over and over again to have more off panal victories than logan...

Originally posted by riceroost
True, but Wolverine pwned Creed in their first ever fight.

True but he had a weapon.

Originally posted by riceroost
Via sneak attack.

I'd call it a sneak attack if wolverie was caught completely unprepared but you have to admit sabretooth toyed with him that entire story..

Originally posted by riceroost
Oh, that fight where Wolverine had Creed pinned and helpless by the end of the fight? Please.

Creed was far from helpless.. wolverine ran away.. 😐

Originally posted by riceroost
Oh yeah, via sneak attack AGAIN, while Wolverine was falling out of a helicopter and carrying on a conversation with Elsie Dee while not even engaged in a fight. Creed didn't do jack shit in that issue to prove any supposed "superiority."

Sabretooth was semi sedated and bound in shackles.. wolverine was completely aware of sabretooth incoming by the time creed got to him.. 😐

Originally posted by riceroost
I suppose Wolverine proved his "superiority" when he cut off Creed's hand while the guy was fighting Black Panther? That seems fair to me.

No because unlike wolverine in issue 42.. sabretooth was COMPLETELY unaware..
Besides.. a hand lost is nothing compared to a jugular exposed so it doesn't even add up that way.

Originally posted by riceroost
Are you high? Wolverine had just got done fighting a HANDICAP fight against Tooth and Lady D. Creed had 1 hand around Wolverine's neck and you call that a win? Bullshit. Not a fiar fight, therefor no winner. Even if it was acceptable Creed has no win. Fight is interupted.

Pfffft.. there was BARELY a fight before the cage crashed and hunter went in to help wolverine.. HARDLY the one sided handicap you're trying to sell here... and no straight winner but sabretooth WAS WINNING.

Originally posted by riceroost
You mean # 90. And was only pwning because Wolverine was holding back in the fight as we have gone over before. Wolverine won that fight..
Wolverine popped a claw through sabes brain when sabretooth TOLD HIM TO.. because you know. sabretooth wanted it.. like he did the entire story arch of being held up in the x-mansion.. 🤨
the point was that sabretooth proved a CLEAR h2h superiority.. if logan had one he sure didn't show it considering the fact that sabretooth was getting more hits in. Wolverine was getting chumped...

and just because he was holding back his claws does not automatically dictate that his fighting ability would suffer.. the fight was fairly one sided and wolverine was getting the worst of it..
And this is again.. AFTER sabretooth forced himself through that force field.. and don't give me that "glow" garbage.. you and I both know that took a bit out of creed considering that he saw that wall as a WORLD o HURT.

Originally posted by riceroost
Due to suprise power-up # 1.

Cop out.

Originally posted by riceroost
Creed hadn't beaten anyone as we have already gone over. He had an advantage in the fight due to suprise power-up # 2

He's got logan on the ropes and logans admiting TO HIMSELF that he might be able to take creed.. ADVANTAGE? CREED.

Originally posted by riceroost
No such thing happened.

Uhh yes it did.. you know when you hear that "krk" noise and wolverine blacks out to their past encounter...
Wolverine only recovered from that because sabretooth let him go.. in shock to the latin comment...

Originally posted by riceroost
Wolverine landed more hits than Creed. Fight ends in double KO. Draw.

Wolverine assumes.. yet who's strapped to the blackbird?
Superior showing? sabretooth.

Originally posted by riceroost
In 51 Wolverine has big advantage over Creed while fighting in the jet. Creed was helpless until the plane crashed, freeing him from Wolverine's strangle hold.

again with this helpless nonsense.. it's like when creed is shackled by BP he must be helpless there to.... ooooor not.. 🙄
and again I suppose attacks from behind are only applicable when it's wolverine attacking... 🙄
and again! sabretooth had a superior showing of durability. simple as.

Originally posted by riceroost
Sorry to say this since I usually hold a lot of respect for your opinion, but you are being blatantly untruthful a lot in this thread.

Not at all.. I'm not being half the hypocrite that you've proven yourself to be here.. that's all.

but who has the bigger wang? not usually the type of question i ask but he who answers correctly will prove his knowledge of these two characters and his opinion will weigh more heavily.

(*thinks about it*)

trick question....

MERC DOES.. 😈

HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAH true true, you are wise, however i meant it, i'm sure you know the x-men ish, where both standing next to eachother at the a urinal, you can gauge from there reactions that one is impressed with the size of the other.

Think to grant morrisons x-men, i'm sure it'll come back to you.

I'm going to have to go with THE LAST RUN on this one and give it to Wolverine 6/10. That story rocked and you cant beat Storm with a mohawk.punk

???? the most recent fight between them i remember (even though marvel promised they wouldn't any more (which was a stupid promise to make in the first place (stupid marvel))) sabes owned completley and emphatically. ripping open wolvie and telling him to !@#$ off and give it up already.

.

Originally posted by riceroost
.
I agree. durfist

QUOTE=8871999]Originally posted by jinzin No.. PART of my reasoning for why I think sabretooth is logan's superior is based
in the fact that Sabretooth is stated over and over and over again to have more off panal victories than logan...
[/QUOTE] And where was that stated? Even if it had been stated before, now it has been retconned. Wolverine does have more victories. Even the Best of Wolverine HC states in the back that Wolverine's record against
Sabretooth is 16-4. Wolverine is obviously ahead. Why would their past battles be so much different then their more recent ones? They wouldn't be. Sabretooth was WEAKER in the past. He didn't have any of his Weapon X strength, speed, durability upgrades.

Originally posted by jinzin True but he had a weapon...
So what? Wolverine uses a weapon in 99 out
of 100 fights. He didn't use his claws, therefor using some other stabbing weapon like a sword doesn't give him any advantage what so ever. In fact it's a weakness as his bone claws can cut through substances a sword cant even scratch. Wolverine beat Sabretooth with an inferior weapon.
Originally posted by jinzin I'd call it a sneak attack if wolverie was caught completely unprepared but you have to admit sabretooth toyed with him that entire story.
Sabretooth hit him from behind. It was a sucker punch plain and simple. Wolverine put his back to the water so Creed would have to come at him from the front, therefor he OBVIOUSLY wasn't ready for an attack from behind. If you are expecting an opponent to come through a door in front of you for a straight up fight and he stabs you from under the couch behind you you are still caught off guard. Wolverine challenged Creed to face him man to man. Creed refused to give Wolverine that fight. It was safer to take the cowards way out and hit him from behind. He didn't even win the fight, he just threw him in the water and it was over. If you call that a win I can call Wolverine cutting his hand off against Panther a win.
Originally posted by jinzin Creed was far from helpless.. wolverine ran away.
He was trapped
under a collapsed tunnel. A tunnel Wolverine collapsed on him in a 1 on 1 fight. Wolverine could have walked over and stabbed him in his exposed face. Wolverine obviously did not run away. That is BS and you know it. Wolverine had to save the morlock healer. He was saving a live. Completely different.
Originally posted by jinzin Sabretooth was semi sedated and bound in shackles.. wolverine was completely
aware of sabretooth incoming by the time creed got to him.
1) You dont know that Sabretooth was sedated. Wolverine suggested it to the Shield agents. There is no clear picture or wording indicating he had been injected yet.

2) Sedating people with healing factors rarely does much of anything for very long.

3) Shackles mean squat to Sabretooth.

4) Wolverine was turned away from Sabretooth, bot fighting, or even looking at him, engaged in conversation with Elsie Dee, who was about to "die." He was not paying any attention to Sabretooth.

5) Sabretooth attacks unaware Wolverine, who is still holding Elsie Dee's head. Wolverine wasn't aware of him until Creed plowed into his side.

6) This is rediculous. You argue about Spider-Man webbing up Wolverine in a non-combat situation, but Sabretooth does basically the same thing (only worse since Wolverine isn't even looking or talking to him) and you argue against Wolverine. You're the one being a massive hypocrite here.

Originally posted by jinzin No because unlike wolverine in issue 42.. sabretooth was COMPLETELY unaware..
And Wolverine was completely unaware in the above situation.
You cant prove at all that he knew what Sabretooth was doing. At least Sabretooth was in battle mode. Wolverine was cuddling a robot sitting on his ass.
Originally posted by jinzin Besides.. a hand lost is nothing compared to a jugular exposed so it doesn't even
add up that way.
A lost hand drastically reduces Sabretooth's fighting ability and 9 times out of 10 he will lose that fight against anyone decent. Wolverine with an exposed jugular still doesn't even have an injury inflicted yet. And so what if he did bite his throat. You yourself have argued that Wolverine wasn't even fazed by have a Katana shoved completely through his throat. Just another wound that heals in a few seconds. Wolverine fights on with throat wounds all the time, which you obviously know. Again you are being a hypocrite.
Originally posted by jinzin Pfffft.. there was BARELY a fight before the cage crashed and hunter went in to
help wolverine.. HARDLY the one sided handicap you're trying to sell here... and no straight winner but sabretooth WAS WINNING.
Bull Shit. Wolverine KOed WENDIGO in 4 panels. Creed and Lady D hammer on Logan for 4 pages straight as a team. The number of panels in a fight does not give any indication of how long a fight lasts. You are being rediculous. Wolverine was fighting Lady D and Creed in a handicap fight long enough to be injured badly enough to fall flat on his face by the time the Hunter intervened. He was badly hurt because of that 2 on 1 fight. You can't deny that. He got injured because of the handicap.

If anything the Hunter clearly proves Wolverine is Sabretooth's superior. Creed needed Lady D's help to fight 1 Hunter. Wolverine by himself (with no adamanium) killed MANY Hunters in Wolverine # 83.

I cant believe you are trying to say Creed was winning. Thats BS too. Creed had a momentary advantage on an unfairly injured Wolverine. So Creed had a hand on Logan's throat, Hulk had his whole hand around Logan's head and slammed him into the ground and Wolverine got right back up in Hulk # 340. Just because you grab someone in no way means you are winning the fight. Creed has no win here. It's a stalemate. Fight is interupted.

Originally posted by jinzin Wolverine popped a claw through sabes brain when sabretooth TOLD HIM TO.. because
you know. sabretooth wanted it.. like he did the entire story arch of being held up in the x-mansion.
It didn't matter if Sabre wanted it or not. Wolverine was in position to do the head pop anyway. Creed only asked Wolverine to do it because he was mocking Wolverine for holding back by doing the middle claw threat. Sabre most likely thought Wolverine was just going to wuss out and lock him up again.
Originally posted by jinzin the point was that sabretooth proved a CLEAR h2h superiority.. if logan had one he
sure didn't show it considering the fact that sabretooth was getting more hits in. Wolverine was getting chumped.
Sabretooth and Wolverine were dead even in H2H, even though Creed WAS using his CLAWS and Wolverine was NOT. Wolverine was fighting evenly with Creed despite Creed's greater speed and strength and his use of his primary weapon. Creed only gets the advantage because of the low blow. Even after the low blow Creed only hits him 3 times and manages to send him to his knees. Then Wolverine gets right back up. It's not like he was getting overwealmed. He got kicked in the junk and Creed had a momentary advantage on a guy thats clearly holding back.
Originally posted by jinzin and just because he was holding back his claws does not automatically dictate that
his fighting ability would suffer.. the fight was fairly one sided and Wolverine was getting the worst of it.
If hes not using his claws he's holding back his MAIN WEAPON. He's not trying to seriously injure Creed. Creed IS using his claws, therefor he's obviously trying to seriously injure Wolvy. Creed is not holding back. Wolverine is. It's a handicap. The fight was only one-sided because Wolverine refused to use his claws on Sabretooth, who then states he is going to kill Wolverine. Wolverine not using the claws isn't trying, it's plain and simple. If Wolverine didn't fight Spider-Man with the claws you would obviously state that he was holding back, why is this so different? Not only that, but it's Creed, who he HATES. Wolverine had to be holding back a lot not to pop on him.

Using the claws makes this a different fight entirely. Wolverine's punches can't possibly inflict as much damage as Creed's claws do on him. Wolverine's main advantage over Creed other than skill is that he can inflict heavier damage. Take that away and Wolverine is holding back against a guy that is stronger and faster. Honestly what chance does Wolverine have against Creed w/o the claws? He could hurt him, stun him, but surely not finish him off. If you fight a guy w/o a weapon in a fashion that you know wont yield a victory you are obviously holding back.

Besides all that Creed is doing his best to KILL Logan at the end of the fight and Wolverine completely turns the fight around in his favor and has Creed at his mercy, still holding back the claws. Pics dont lie. Creed got flattened.

After Wolverine finally gets pissed all of Creed's "superiority" vanishes.

Originally posted by jinzin And this is again.. AFTER sabretooth forced himself through that force field.. and don't give me that "glow" garbage.
It's not garbage when Creed blatantly compares it to the Glow (which doesn't even hurt him), only saying it's not even that effective.
Originally posted by jinzin Cop out.
How the **** is that a cop out? If an opponent you know better than yourself randomly shows up with a huge upgrade it's going to suprise you and put you at a disadvantage. Wolverine thought his blows would have the same effect that they usually did, but they didn't as Creed had the metal bones and the suddenly better HF. It's like fighting a completely new opponent, one that has even more advantages than normal.
Originally posted by jinzin He's got logan on the ropes and logans admiting TO HIMSELF that he might be able to
take creed.. ADVANTAGE? CREED.
Creed had no win here. He had an advantage, and Logan is undecided about who will win. That in no way means he is beat. Creed had an advantage, not a win.
Originally posted by jinzin Uhh yes it did.. you know when you hear that "krk" noise and wolverine blacks out to
their past encounter.
So what if there was a noise? What does a noise prove? Nothing. Wolverine had a flashback that lasted about a milisecond. Wolverine was still standing. It's not like he was KOed and laying in the dirt while Creed giggled. He ripped out Logan's spine, Wolverine experiences his little dream state that it is established in # 48 he goes into while healing, and is still on his feet. The story is told from Logan's POV. Creed could have been momentarily blacking out after Logan's strikes. Creed's attack didn't even knock Wolverine over. Wolverine was probably still fighting while it was going on like he seems to be doing during his little rage in # 51.
Originally posted by jinzin Wolverine only recovered from that because sabretooth let him go.. in shock to the
latin comment.
Did you see Creed let him go? No. We come out of the flashback and see Wolverine standing there unaffected by Creed's attack. You have no idea what happened.
Originally posted by jinzin Wolverine assumes.. yet who's strapped to the blackbird?
So because he assumed it means he's wrong? He stabbed him in the head. I'm willing to assume Creed was KOed. Double KO is a draw. Wolverine assumes Creed woke up first, but he also thinks Creed had help. There is no way to know how Wolverine got tied up, or how he got to the plane, or how Creed was flying the plane. Someone could have helped him like Panther, Wild Child, or the other animals we see in # 53. I doubt Creed was the one who chained him. Creed should have known there was no way chains would hold Wolverine. He wouldn't have bothered with something that wouldn't work. Someone could have helped Creed get into the jet and set up auto pilot, while someone elsestrapped Wolverine in. Creed wakes up in the air right when Wolvy does.
Originally posted by jinzin Superior showing? sabretooth.
Getting a claw shoved through your brain is not a superior showing. Creed also had the easier wound to heal. Punctures will heal faster than Wolverine's injury. Wolverine's organ was ripped out of his body. Healing cuts takes less time to heal than regenerating missing flesh. He was still KOed and that means draw.
Originally posted by jinzin again with this helpless nonsense.. it's like when creed is shackled by BP he must
be helpless there to.
Creed was unable to get away from Wolverine. He was getting choked out until the impact. The impact saved him. advantage: Wolverine. Being shackled by Panther is meaningless. Creed had Panther, Logan, Storm, and Wakandan guards shackle him. Dont get what your point is. Being shackled by a group of people in anoutnumbered situation is completely different than Wolverine throttling you in a 1 on 1 fight.
Originally posted by jinzin and again I suppose attacks from behind are only applicable when it's wolverine
attacking.
WTF are you babbling about? Sabretooth constantly blindsides Wolverine in non-combat, or sneak attack situations when he's distracted. Wolverine got behind Sabretooth in a 1 on 1 fight where both were actually in the process of hitting each other. Wolverine got behind Creed and throttled him because he's a better fighter.
Originally posted by jinzin and again! sabretooth had a superior showing of durability.
So? We already know Creed is more durable than Wolverine. Creed got a durability up-grade from his last Weapon X stint. When you get into a wreck your injuries are not determined by who is more durable. Creed could have landed on grass and Wolverine could have landed with a burning part of the wing shoved through his gut. It all up to chance. Wolverine's injuries looked worse, but Creed still had bones in his right leg, right ribcage, and his right arm showing. You could also see through Creed's right flank, as the sky is visible where flesh is missing. By the time Storm gets there they are both similarly healed. Both of them still have muscle tissue visible on their right sides. By the last page Wolverine looks normal and Creed still has a singed scalp.
Originally posted by jinzin Not at all.. I'm not being half the hypocrite that you've proven yourself to be here.. that's all.
I'm not the one contradicting my own arguments from other threads. That's you. I'm also not the one misrepresenting information. You are clearly doing that, or it's been so long since you read these comics you dont remember.

Wolverine got more experience, and skills, plus he'll go beserk on sabes

There is one instance when wolverine is captured by apocalypse and he makes sabertooth and wolverine fight to see who deserves to be his horseman....sabertooth has the adamantium skeleton in this fight....logan had his bone claws......this is the most telling moment between them i.m.o....it shows logan knows how to beat a regenerating adamantium laced foe....and to top it off its sabertooth.........he knows what is at stake and is serious from the get go........

I do understand all the upgrades sabertooth has had...and his relentless pursuit of logan...but i always felt wolverine was the superior...well thats just my opinon......this has always been a good debate i.m.o

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
[b]Wolverine - First Class #9

Wolverine vs. Sabretooth!

[/B]

😖hifty: