Barker vs Thorinn

Barker's entry is cleared. I will post my judging tomorrow morning when I'm clearheaded enough to write out a judging report.

Thorinn:

🙂 Mood
😐 Background
🙁 Lighting is wrong
🙁 Integration of the render is weird.

Barker:

🙂 Contrast
😐 Background is a nice attempt, but blending is a little iffy sometimes
🙁 Harry Potter ❌
🙁 Layout is really unbalanced

Winner: Barker

Barker's sig is better overall. What The deciding blow was Thorinn's overintegration of the hair on the render, but not the face. The render is then enveloped in a background that is too underdevelped to be the main focus of the piece.

GOOD JOB DUELISTS

wave

wave

OMG JUG ALRED

Originally posted by Alliance

Thorinn:

🙂 Mood
😐 Background
🙁 Lighting is wrong
🙁 Integration of the render is weird.

Barker:

🙂 Contrast
😐 Background is a nice attempt, but blending is a little iffy sometimes
🙁 Harry Potter ❌
🙁 Layout is really unbalanced

Winner: Thorinn

Thorinn's sig is better overall. What The deciding blow was Barker's overintegration of the Harry Potter on the render, but not the face. The render is then enveloped in a background that is too underdevelped to be the main focus of the piece.

GOOD JOB DUELISTS