YAY someone to debate with!!! 🙂 hooray! okay... down to business...
well technically, Will is also an outlaw now. Will and Elizabeth both basically have the death penalty in port Royal
so Jack would actually be the more stable choice, considering he is a more experienced pirate, has a ship, and has uncanny luck for getting out of scrapes.
first kiss or best kiss? i think i'd go with best kiss. 😉
any more arguments?
Knowing some one from childhood doesn't mean you would love them more than some one you just meet. It all depends on the person. I don't think Will could actually handle Elizabeth's pirate side when it comes out. And believe me, it'll come out sooner or later. The point is, you see Will drag Elizabeth back to Port Royal where she has distinctly put a negative outlook on. He put her in a corset, which she has said she dispises time and time again.
He does all this and he doesn't let her pirate side out. He doesn't even know she has a pirate side. He can't connect with her, and Jack can.
There are thousands of reasons why they should be together. I'll post again with my other post from awhile back. I've heard that it could sum up my Will isn't good for Elizabeth point pretty good.
That's the point. He's a pushover, she needs some one who's alittle rougher and tougher like Jack.
Here
----------
Honestly, the compass.
What is the whole point of the compass? It points to what you want in the WORLD, and it pointed to Jack more than once while resting in Elizabeth's hands. Not everything Elizabeth does is for Will, though most of the things Will does is for Elizabeth.
He needs to get a hobby. Lol.
Elizabeth isn't just a woman. She isnt' just a puzzle piece that's only purpose in life is to fit into the picture of a man. She's a human being, she's selfish, she's disloyal, she's dishonest and coniving. Decietful and cunning, witty and brave.
She's a pirate.
Will is an honest man, he doesn't lie or cheat or kill or steal. He's a hard worker and he doesn't much like the wind in his face, whipping his hair. He wants a normal life, to settle in a town and raise a family, he wants a wife. To make Lizzie a wife, the woman whom bares him his children.
He's not a pirate.
There's a difference between his blood and his actions. He may have a pirate father, a man whom has sailed the seas and seen all there is to see, but that doesn't mean he will be that man as well.
He's a different man and a different person. His blood may have something to do in his life, but in this case, the only purpose it serves is running through his viens.
Will treats Elizabeth like a porcline doll, I've said this millions of times, he only wants to shine her up and let the world see her in his little cupboard. What do we see when in the begining of DMC? A poor, disheveled Lizzie wearing another one of those tight corsets, and rain soakes the wedding dress as she sits there alone.
Elizabeth could fight with Jack, cut him, burn him, stab him but he will always fight back. If she told Will to shut up and find another woman, what would he do? He'd think she wants him gone and just put his tail between his legs and scamper off before he bursts into tears. But Jack would stay there, and he'd question her, fight with her and make her love him again.
See the difference?
Two people like this can't work out. Sure opposites attract, but when the woman in the relationship wears the pants...really...would that work?
No.
I have no doubt that Will would do anything for Elizabeth, but I don't think Elizabeth is so one dimentional that all she has in her life is the priority to look after her 'man'. Cause we already know she's not one of those corset wearing, prim and proper ladies stuck in their drawing rooms all day. Right?
So why would the pirate at heart give up her freedom for a man she's doubting loving? Guilt is the only reason I see.
So yes, I believe her and Will might end up together in AWE, but purley because of guilt.
Guilt.