If this ship goes down, you aren't the only one going down with it, hun. Actually, i take it back. The ship isn't going down at all. Just because the movie ends W/E doesn't mean that J/E never existed, or that it still doesn't exist. Hell, we don't even know how it ends! Sure there are tons of things that point to a W/E ending, it makes sense. But don't say we just misinterpreted all the signs, because we didn't. The makers of this film made this happen for a reason. The writers are so great, we know they made it so. Jack and Elizabeth were meant to be, and they could be. The compass was not pointless. The dress was not pointless. Many things in the movie we probably over-analyzed, yes. But it is wrong to say that all the clues we found for J/E were meaningless. And there are not JUST clues. There is big in-your-face evidence. And I don't even know why I'm rambling about it, because we've had months of discussion and debate on it.
So many people love Jack and Elizabeth together. I do,and so do many other people on this forum. Maybe we're all just stupid and blind for thinking so. But I like being stupid, then. I love Jack and Elizabeth. They are so amazing together, and I will be a silly fangirl forever.
So, maybe all evidence points to a W/E ending. But you can count on me, to be sitting in my theatre seat, over analyzing every 'clue', and squealing when ever Jack and Elizabeth are on screen together. And, even when the movie ends, and it ends with Will and Elizabeth married, I will secretly snicker at the people who don't believe that Will and Elizabeth break up and Jack and Liz live happily after anyways. But even if I'm wrong, and the ship does go down, be proud to go down on the good ship Sparrabeth, the most amazing, hot, sexy, true, loving, lustful, beautiful, complicated, simple ship the world has ever known!