I Like Ultimate Better

Started by H. S. 610 pages

Originally posted by Grimm22
He's still badass, he's still Wolverine

He hasn't really made jokes or anything like that, it's just shows a different side of Wolverine

And actually, I love astonishing Wolverine, it brings me back to Classic Wolverine days

👆

Originally posted by Grimm22
He's still badass, he's still Wolverine

He hasn't really made jokes or anything like that, it's just shows a different side of Wolverine

And actually, I love astonishing Wolverine, it brings me back to Classic Wolverine days


👆

Originally posted by Validus
👆

👆

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
Wolverine has done some badass stuff in Astonishing.

And bringing his kid persona on wasn't really off-character - there is no denying it, Wolverine was a pussy while he was a kid. One of the pussiest kids I have ever seen, actually.


that never should have worked. You know the amount of times logan been un control able or even able to be mest with on a phyic level. That enevr should have happen and if you look back through his history the only times he been mested with a phyic level mean from a phyic attack has all been in astonishing x-men.

Originally posted by Grimm22
He's still badass, he's still Wolverine

yes and no he more or less a joke in astonishing and is portrayed nothing like the normal wolverine on average.

Originally posted by Grimm22
He hasn't really made jokes or anything like that, it's just shows a different side of Wolverine

different side? No it showing another character that is not logan. Yes he has some rare good moments how ever he made to look like a joke constantly it quite dumb and totaly against his character.

A

Originally posted by Grimm22
[Bnd actually, I love astonishing Wolverine, it brings me back to Classic Wolverine days [/B]

It nothing like clasic wolverine. You just enjoy seeing logan look dumb that all.

He written out of character repeatedly through out astonishing x-men.

Originally posted by nimbus006
I think where the Panther stories are right now are great. I'm just glad he is finally getting some respect in the Marvel Universe. Finally, he is palying a major role.

Yea i agree Astonishing is great. I'd give it 3 1/2 if there was a half star on my key board. 😄

I'm talking about current F4, so yea CW tie-in F4.

Yeah, I guess you could consider BP to be a good book, you know if you ignore the shallow writing and repetitive drive by Hudlin to make everyone in the MU who he doesn't like Racist?!?

Seriously, Doom himself is half-gypsy, why the **** would he be racist?!?

Obviously Capt hasn't read the latest issue of Astonishing

I just love one line:

Beast: And You?

Wolveirne: Had a beer

Beast: Same basic principle

(Note: This is after Beast explains how he got out of Nova's Mind Control)

Originally posted by Grimm22
Obviously Capt hasn't read the latest issue of Astonishing

I just love one line:

Beast: And You?

Wolveirne: Had a beer

Beast: Same basic principle

(Note: This is after Beast explains how he got out of Nova's Mind Control)


I know what happen and I read astonishing I never said it was bad I said it characterization of logan is out of character.

Originally posted by Grimm22
Obviously Capt hasn't read the latest issue of Astonishing

I just love one line:

Beast: And You?

Wolveirne: Had a beer

Beast: Same basic principle

(Note: This is after Beast explains how he got out of Nova's Mind Control)

That was a great line.

Another one:

Wolverine: Pfft! That's what friends are for.

Beast: I'm fairly certain it's not.

Whedon impresses me with every issue. He delivers some great lines. 😂

Originally posted by H. S. 6
That was a great line.

Another one:

Wolverine: Pfft! That's what friends are for.

Beast: I'm fairly certain it's not.

Whedon impresses me with every issue. He delivers some great lines. 😂

Indeed 😄 😆

I can't wait till the next issue. It took me a couple times to figure out the entire situation, but now I understand it

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
Wolverine has done some badass stuff in Astonishing.

And bringing his kid persona on wasn't really off-character - there is no denying it, Wolverine was a pussy while he was a kid. One of the pussiest kids I have ever seen, actually.

😆

Origins was great though....but he was still a pussy.

Sometimes the Ultimate universe is nice...

But I still prefer 616...for now.

Originally posted by capt it up
I know what happen and I read astonishing I never said it was bad I said it characterization of logan is out of character.

Let's seee, Logan still is the gruff Badass with an additude 😐

How the hell is that out of character?!?

Originally posted by Grimm22
Let's seee, Logan still is the gruff Badass with an additude 😐

How the hell is that out of character?!?

It's not, silly goose.

Capt is just angry that Logan isn't his current uber-healing-star-of-the-show self.

Originally posted by capt it up
I know what happen and I read astonishing I never said it was bad I said it characterization of logan is out of character.

try dating girls instead of canadians.

😗

Originally posted by Soljer
Successful and good are not entire mutually exclusive, true.

But they aren't entire inclusive, either.

For example, I may believe that a film that goes into existential issues is a better film than a action-packed-summer-blockbuster, because it makes me think, and I enjoy philosophy. However, the blockbuster may very well make more at the box office.

There are plenty of cult films that are GREAT films, but not particularly successful ones.

In summation; sometimes media (in all its forms, comics included) cater to the masses. When this happens, the quality may very well be decreased in order to please everyone. The quality of the story might even go to SHIT, so long as everyone's happy. Is the book necessarily better just because more people like it? ❌

Not to disagree with you, but you do you ever wonder if the majority of people like or enjoy something ( such as a movie, book, etc...), but for some reason you don't, cuz you think its shit, then maybe you're the one that has bad taste in quality.

And I'm not being sarcastic or anything, Im honestly asking, cuz alot of the time i feel the same way you do, and i ask myself maybe I'm the one with poor taste... just some food for thought.

Originally posted by nimbus006
Not to disagree with you, but you do you ever wonder if the majority of people like or enjoy something ( such as a movie, book, etc...), but for some reason you don't, cuz you think its shit, then maybe you're the one that has bad taste in quality.

And I'm not being sarcastic or anything, Im honestly asking, cuz alot of the time i feel the same way you do, and i ask myself maybe I'm the one with poor taste... just some food for thought.

There is no "poor taste," just as there is no right or wrong opinion.

Thats what i always say, howver some people have really strong opinions.

Originally posted by Zahit
try dating girls instead of canadians.

😗

wait wait wait wait. Do you really think there are no canadian girls?

any ways I not into canadians I like irish girls

Originally posted by H. S. 6
It's not, silly goose.

Capt is just angry that Logan isn't his current uber-healing-star-of-the-show self.

Not at all I just do like seeing a serous character star making dumb jokes all the time. I also don't like seing a character known for his mind being to hard to control running around like a little girl. I also don't like hearing the comic writter state he has no idea how to write "wolverine".