Nightmare Movie Casting

Started by roughrider1 pages

Nightmare Movie Casting

Name some big stars who would be absolutely wrong for comic book movie roles.

Like, for me:

THE MIGHTY THOR

Starring as Thor - Owen Wilson
As Loki - Luke Wilson (his brother)

😈

I will ignore you rider.

Originally posted by redcaped
I will ignore you rider.

Who's talking to you anyway? 🙄

well, we can start here...

Originally posted by morethandork
People, people, come on! Everyone has picked Brandon Routh as superman? I liked the movie, sure, but i would never pick him if I had a choice. C'mon now. Dig deep. Think! Who would really be good for these roles. Not just of what teenage heart-throb of the last 6 months would be good, but, of all actors avaliable today!

First of all, which green lantern are we talking about here? People have assumed Hal Jordan, but he left (demolished) the GL corpse ages ago. I think a new JLA would cast the young buck (i forget his name).

Also, I personally feel most superheroes should be played by relative unknown actors because, if history is any lesson (catwoman, daredevil, the league, elektra), casting a star in the lead is a kiss of death for comic movies.

But since we can't cast unknowns 'cause we don't know them, here's my list:

Superman: Ben Kingsley (25 years ago, it'd be Paul Newman)
Batman: Denzel Washington
Wonder Woman: Vivica A Fox (15 Years ago, it'd be Cher)
Green Lantern: Johnny Depp
Flash: Matt Damon (though I like Reynolds for this too)
Martian Manhunter: Anthony Hopkins
Aquaman: Chris Cooper
Green Arrow: Harrison Ford
Plasticman: Jim Carrey of course
Powergirl: Jodie Foster
Vixen: Queen Latifah

Originally posted by redcaped
I will ignore you rider.

If you're ignoring him, why are you posting in his thread?

Holy God. Some awesome WTF casting there. Ben Kingsley as Superman? Denzel Washington as Batman? Chris Cooper? Queen Latifah?

Here's another-

Wonder Woman - Rosie O'Donnell. 😘

(They once thought she'd be great as Betty Rubble. Idiots.)

What about this "Jack Black as Green Lantern" thing that's been going around? Add that to the horrors of casting lol

Originally posted by NoFate007
What about this "Jack Black as Green Lantern" thing that's been going around? Add that to the horrors of casting lol

Yes, that's ugly. I don't why it won't go away - Black himself has condemned the script he's seen as 'silly'.