Twilight Princess Link vs. Ocarina of Time Link

though i haven't beaten TP yet, i was thinking about this and i realized that the TP Link has some of the best arching reflexes in the series, but the OoT Link had some pretty mean magic up his sleeve... your thoughts?

It depends can Twilight Link turn into his wolf form, and get midna on his back. If so he wins

my thoughts are in wonder, I'm still decided on 360 or Wii, so i haven't so much as looked at it yet.

I'd say that OoT link have the superior magic, since you say, and if the other Link is the bette archer then i think it should go back to the old fanishon way..... whos the better swordsman and does TP Link have Master sword?

yes. Actually he even gets the Light Sword which is superior

I have to give it to the Twilight Princess Link. He seems to be a better horseback rider, archer, and swordsman with equal or superior magic.

I want a Wii just to play Twilight Princess T_T

On topic I can't tell since I haven't seen what the new Link is capable of.

Link does'nt use magic in TP

since TP Link definitely has more (and better) sword techniques, better horse-riding technique, and i guess you could count turning into a wolf as magic (not necessarily his own, but hey)

TP definately gets this

Since I don't own TP until tomorrow, I'm not gonna make an argument for him, however, I do have to say that I have heard nothing about specific powers such as invinsibility, a fire wall that just expands around him. And the sword part, well unless you got some of the feats performed I only see that as gameplay! I mean, like saying WW Link is above Adult OOT Link in swordsmanship, which would hardly be logical!

Link does have this cool, red and gold magic armor that makes him invinsible. But it drains rupee for usage

damn this is tough...but im going with TP..older, better sword/horse/arrows skills (though this could just be game mechanics)..
also, he does have the superior light sword, like tallis said, and the wolf form with minda, and that would give him a definate edge..so im going with TP..

Older? How old is he? I thought he was like 16, is he 18? OOT is 17!

Anyway, I can't still make a stand, and it got delayed until friday! :@

here is the problem with compairing thies two

as soon as OoT link gets on the horse he is invincible

you never ran into any poes then i assume...

and TP's swordsmanship is superior, learning your sword skills is a big part of the game

The Light Sword is only superior against Twilight beasts. It's just the Master Sword filled with light for the purpose of dispelling darkness and dark creatures. Against the average Lizalfos or Darknut, it does no extra damage.

I dunno if I could call this one, though. TP Link doesn't use magic at all, while OoT Link has Nayru's Love, a time-limited impenetrable shield. TP Link has better archery skill, but OoT Link has elemental arrows. Then again, TP Link also has bomb arrows.

TP Link is by far the better swordsman, but OoT Link has the Biggoron's Sword.

I say after a long, grueling battle that has depleted all of both their disposable items, TP Link wins by a couple hearts.

I think the Ocarina of Time Link is better. Even though the TP one has all the skills and stuff, OoT Link was a better hero.

TP link is way better than OOT link in swordmanship , right at the beggining all of the OOT links moves were considered useless for the golden wolf , In the end of the game link is already a master swordsman much better than the old link. In his wolf form link has some intant kill abilities that seem pretty nasty . Although the TP link doesnt have any magic at all , he has "evolutions " of the OOT items , like the dual clawshot , the boomerang with the wind god inside it , etc

TP link wins most of OoT link magic was short ranged and the magic arrows can be blocked by the sheild strike knocking them back or back at him OoT was not very good swordman compared to TP link and his wolf form is alot quicker and harser to hit though lower defence and TP links bombarrows have the knock back advantage tossing OoT backwards from the explosion

And the sword part, well unless you got some of the feats performed I only see that as gameplay! I mean, like saying WW Link is above Adult OOT Link in swordsmanship, which would hardly be logical!

^
that is a excellent point man, and that proves theres real no way to say who is a better swords men,i'm glad you said it, thumbs up

i'm gonna say OOT link, with all that magic and all,and the gold gauntlets makes him pretty ****in strong, and weather tp is a better swordsmen (or archer) is hard to say since it could just be game play,so even bringing up that would be pointless, and as for tp turning into a wolf thats only in the twligth relm,so i wouldn't count on that to help, i'm gonna give this one to OOT link,

plus in majora's mask he gets all those mask so he could just use those couldn't he? Fierce Deity Mask would be the last thing TP link would wanna mess with