Your favourite battle

😆

Why are you laughing? I was serious. Come up with one solid argument against that scene?

It was a pointless waste of time. There was no reason to land, they were clearly not under threat. All that you said could have easily been done as they were flying off into space.

There WAS a reason!! They had no place to go and needed time to see if they could fix the hyperdrive. Going into the asteroid field was hopefully going to shake off the Empire... they failed. So all they could do was stop, try to fix the hyperdrive and then leave the asteroid field to make the jump. All very good and clever writing there. Plus, as I said, it gave a good moment for the fairly important romance.

Just as a side note:
Would Mustafar be considered a battle or a duel?

Originally posted by queeq
There WAS a reason!! They had no place to go and needed time to see if they could fix the hyperdrive. Going into the asteroid field was hopefully going to shake off the Empire... they failed. So all they could do was stop, try to fix the hyperdrive and then leave the asteroid field to make the jump. All very good and clever writing there. Plus, as I said, it gave a good moment for the fairly important romance.

i never argued the asteroid field, I argued LANDING...and the LANDING in a worm.

Nothing about that sequence was clever.

Originally posted by Marxman
Just as a side note:
Would Mustafar be considered a battle or a duel?

they LANDED to try and fix teh hyperdrive..... You said there was no reason for it. I just explained there was a very good reason for it. If you can'tshake the Empire because your hyperdrive isn't working, you have to find a place where you can fix it.... Pure and simple logic. It led to the immortal line: "You wanted to be there if I made a mistake, this could be it, princess."
I think you just missed part of that movie...

Then why is it a choice in this poll? I thought this was favorite battles.

Dunno... lame poll.

Originally posted by queeq
they LANDED to try and fix teh hyperdrive..... You said there was no reason for it. I just explained there was a very good reason for it. If you can'tshake the Empire because your hyperdrive isn't working, you have to find a place where you can fix it.... Pure and simple logic. It led to the immortal line: "You wanted to be there if I made a mistake, this could be it, princess."
I think you just missed part of that movie...

They've fixed it in flight before!

Originally posted by Marxman
Then why is it a choice in this poll? I thought this was favorite battles.

Because the guys a newb.

Yeah, with asteroids slamming on them, shields being destroyed, fighters all around... a pause will be nice. Sorry pal, ESb is virtually perfect, every scene has a purpose and leads to the next phase. By far better than any clone film.

They had no problem flying OUT of the field later.

Originally posted by Alliance
They've fixed it in flight before!

Because the guys a newb.

The funny thing is that 5 people voted for it

Yes. Its funny that people have voted in here at all.

Originally posted by Alliance
They had no problem flying OUT of the field later.

So? The problem was not getting OUT of the field, the problem was getting rid of the Empire. Vader ordered them to move out of the asteroid field. Where does it say they didn't know how to leave the asteroid field? If they did with an unrepaired hyperdrive, they'd be sitting ducks for the Empire.
So all it was, was a safe stop to get that hyperdive fixed. I don't see the problem at all.

Unlike AOTC that has many scenes that raise questions (like Syfo-Dyas) and never get resolved. ESB rules.

Argh...this agument makes no sense anymore.

Syfo-Dyas sucked. It should have been Qui-Gon.

Whatever... but AOTC sucked just like Syfo-Dyas did.

HEY! 😠

Baseless accusations.

Originally posted by queeq
Whatever... but AOTC sucked just like Syfo-Dyas did.

Best post I've read in weeks.