The Best Potions Maker

Started by Xandico3 pages
Xandico Senior Member

But what about Dumbledore? He was just like... AMAZING!!!

Elessea Senior Member

Most of Voldemort's stuff has been developed by Snape- seeing sa he works for him developing potions.

Demonic Phoenix Senior Member
Originally posted by Xandico
But what about Dumbledore? He was just like... AMAZING!!!

So is Snape at Potion making😛.

But besides, I think Dumbledore preferred to have Snape develop the potions, rather than do it himself, as demonstrated when he told(I don't think it was shown in POA) Snape to make the Wolfsbane potion for Remus.

siriuswriter Senior Member

Voldemort would have to be pretty damn good to make that green stuff from the cave in HBP...

Xandico Senior Member

IF he made it himself

Demonic Phoenix Senior Member
Originally posted by Xandico
IF he made it himself

He probably did, or he instructed someone to do it, which means he knew how to make it.

Denniz234 Maybe someday...

can i just ask, does it really matter who the best potions maker is?

Blue_Hefner Senior Member
Originally posted by Denniz234
can i just ask, does it really matter who the best potions maker is?

Is no the answer to this question?

Demonic Phoenix Senior Member
Originally posted by Denniz234
can i just ask, does it really matter who the best potions maker is?

No, you cannot ask13😐.

Denniz234 Maybe someday...
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
No, you cannot ask13😐.

Please 🙁
I'll let you answer it 😄 and i have chocolate cake 😉

siriuswriter Senior Member

But then, R.A.B. would've had to be a really good potions maker as well, to replace the green stuff in the cave...

Demonic Phoenix Senior Member
Originally posted by Denniz234
Please 🙁
I'll let you answer it 😄 and i have chocolate cake 😉

pukeI hate chocolate cake, well virtual chocolate cake that islookaround

Xandico Senior Member
Originally posted by siriuswriter
But then, R.A.B. would've had to be a really good potions maker as well, to replace the green stuff in the cave...

Who says that it isn't so clever that it replaces itself?

Denniz234 Maybe someday...
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
pukeI hate chocolate cake, well virtual chocolate cake that islookaround

Whats wrong with virtual chocolate cake? it tastes good and it doesnt make you fat.

Demonic Phoenix Senior Member
Originally posted by Denniz234
Whats wrong with virtual chocolate cake? it tastes good and it doesnt make you fat.

It ain't real😬

Sunlight_shines ..bored..

Originally posted by Xandico
Who says that it isn't so clever that it replaces itself?

So,its either R.A.B. or Snape?
Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
It ain't real😬

-Brings a strawberry cake-you gotta tell whose better now😈

Demonic Phoenix Senior Member

I said Snape😛.

Sunlight_shines ..bored..

ok

[=Luffyz=] Potions-I'd do it for him

2 Words..

Totally Snape.

S-N-A-P-E ROX!! ^-^

Superguy Senior Member

Re: The Best Potions Maker

Originally posted by trolly_crouchjr
1.Snape
2.Lily Evans
3.Slughorn
4.Dumbledore
any others?
It's impossible to know, and potion-making talent isn't exactly easy to judge...
1) So we know Snape's good at potions, and we have had good proof towards his being good, but...
2) All we know about Lily was that Slughorn liked her.
3) All we know about Slughorn is he can brew 4 or 5 potions and taught Lily and Severus.
4) When have we ever seen Dumbledore brew a potion????