Gilbert Arenas vs Tracy McGrady

Who's the better player currently? I say GA#0

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Who's the better player currently? I say GA#0

Tmac 😠

How so?

I would take T-Mac and this season is the one that is finally making me like the guy. T-Mac is finally showing the teamwork and leadership it takes to win. Gilbert for the most part just scores.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
How so?

Tmac is the better all around player.

Score,assist,defense,dunk,rebound etc...

Please not another "who's better thread." Just bring it up in the NBA thread.

And T-mac is overall better. More versatile, stronger, and bigger threat to other teams because he drives more often.

For Tmac to be MORE better then Arenas, he needs to get healthy, but still he is better.

Arenas only because of T-Mac's back issues.

Darth Martin, do u want this when each are healthy or right now in the league or what?

Originally posted by Lord Evolution
Tmac is the better all around player.

Score,assist,defense,dunk,rebound etc...

Just had to clear that up, but then again McGrady isn't playing right now and GA#0 isn't that great of a defender either.

Thank you.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Even though I hate disagreeing with my fellow beloved Laker fans I just have to say Tracy McGrady has no defense. His offence is outstanding.....or was. But his defense.......uhhhhhhh. In Orlando he got his coach fired because he didn't know how to read a zone defense. Part of this is because he never went to college.

Just had to clear that up, but then again McGrady isn't playing right now and GA#0 isn't that great of a defender either.

Gilbert Arenas is one of the worst defenders in the league.....

Originally posted by RecSpecs110
Please not another "who's better thread." Just bring it up in the NBA thread.

And T-mac is overall better. More versatile, stronger, and bigger threat to other teams because he drives more often.

Originally posted by TaZ#12
Darth Martin, do u want this when each are healthy or right now in the league or what?

Originally posted by Lord Evolution
Gilbert Arenas is one of the worst defenders in the league.....

Even if defense wasnt included, I would still chose Tmac.

They both have good teams when each are healthy. But I think TMacs team is more dependent on him than Arenas' team of him. The Rockets are like 0 and 8 without TMAC!

Originally posted by Darth Martin
They both have good teams when each are healthy. But I think TMacs team is more dependent on him than Arenas' team of him. The Rockets are like 0 and 8 without TMAC!

So...How does that fact contribute to your argument of Arenas being better?

Aren't we talking about Arenas or Tmac without the team? I mean the team shouldn't be excluded but still.

Originally posted by RecSpecs110
So...How does that fact contribute to your argument of Arenas being better?