Obi wan has trained you well !

Ok Vader says this line to luke in all three movies why ?? He hates obi wan but he still talks about him 😕

Is it another idea by GL ? 🙄

He says it in episode 4? 😕

People still talkl about things if they hate them, I hate a lot of things that I still talk about. OB1 didn't even train Luke that much, Yoda did more.

Vader didn't know about Yoda. He assumed that Obi-Wan had taught him

All those who hate Bush still talk about him, don't they?

Why wouldn't Vader still mention Obi-Wan when he's facing down his son whom he knows was trained by his old master whom he hasn't seen in 20-some years?

i think there is a little bit of respect still there for Obi
not because of his faith but great warriors and all that
ive had a beer
clouded my judgement is

He says it in ESB and ROTJ

lol why did you say all three. Have you seen episode 4?

"I've been waiting for you Obi Wan. We meet again at last."

This line was edited from:

"I've been waiting for you, Obi Wan has trained you well. We meet again at last."

He mever says it in ANH.... he never even meets Luke face-to-face.

Originally posted by coolmovies
Ok Vader says this line to luke in all three movies why ?? He hates obi wan but he still talks about him 😕

Is it another idea by GL ? 🙄

Because Vader is impressed with the sudden increase to skill level and handling of the Force Luke shows. He is able to resist the dark side and keep his emotions at bay in Episode VI which Vader finds impressive because he would have never been able to do that when he was Luke's age.

Originally posted by ESB -1138
Because Vader is impressed with the sudden increase to skill level and handling of the Force Luke shows. He is able to resist the dark side and keep his emotions at bay in Episode VI which Vader finds impressive because he would have never been able to do that when he was Luke's age.

Originally posted by Tangible God
coolmovies wasn't asking why Vader keeps commenting on his skill, but rather why he keeps mentioning Obi-Wan.

Because Anakin was trained by Obi-Wan and he didn't resist the dark side as much as Luke who was also trained by Kenobi. That's my guess.

Wow, what a useless thread. Let's answer this question once and for all and end it.

Vader tells Luke he was well trained by Obi-Wan in Empire and Jedi because he didn't expect Luke to be that powerful in the Force, considering there aren't any Jedi left to train him, as far as he knows. Remember, Vader has NO idea Yoda is still around. He goes on to assume it's been Obi-Wan that has trained him all these years up to the the point Vader kills him on the Death Star in A New Hope. When Vader sees how powerful Luke really is, he HAS to give props to the training he believes Obi-Wan has to have given Luke. Especially considering he thinks of Obi-Wan as a failure.

Hope this helps answer this question. 🙂

[QUOTE=7969409]Originally posted by Tangible God
[B]All those who hate Bush still talk about him, don't they?

very good point. 😄

😂

ya thanks alot guys

Originally posted by coolmovies
Ok Vader says this line to luke in all three movies why ?? He hates obi wan but he still talks about him 😕

Is it another idea by GL ? 🙄

I'm guessing Vader somehow saw Luke before Luke shot at the door, and Vader assumed Luke came with Obi-Wan.

Really??????????

I think he was more trying to play to Luke's emotions. Like, OB1 trained you well, let me, your father complete your training, and we'll kick ass from there. He basically said that anyway, but thats why I think he mentioned it. And sesse...what the hell are you talking about? Both those lines imply talking to a completely different person...it wasn't edited from that.

ME talks about the truth! Me talks about the gorge lucus!