I am Immortal because my soul is..

Started by Lord Urizen7 pages
Originally posted by FistOfThe North
My belief that I have a soul makes it a fact in itself, to me. And fact is fact. It's definitely not an opinion because my faith tells me that i certainly have a soul because an opinion is a belief or judgment that rests on grounds insufficient to produce complete certainty, while totally killing the soundness of your argument and claim, which is that a soul doesn't exist. So you try again.

That makes absolutely no sense 👇

You are arguing that your opinion is fact, because you believe it is fact, and since "fact is fact", your opinion is not opinion.

Then you argue that you have evidense to back up your opinion, but do provide it....

As Adam Poe said, Try again

Originally posted by Storm
If they can' t be proven, then there is no rational reason to believe they would exist.

Not necessarily.....since matter and energy cannot be created or destroyed, it is logical to beleive that we don't simply cease to be once we die.

Ask yourself...

What is your most purest being ? Are you actually your body ? Are you actually your mind ?

Or are you the composition of everything that makes you exist ?

If so, then that means the food you eat is also "you", and the thoughts you think are also "you"

Does that sound plausible ?

Some people resort to the beleif in a soul, because it's difficult to imagine that we can still exist after death, independent of our bodies and thoughts, without some other enduring substance.

And it's even more difficult to beleive that we simply cease to be, since nothing in science truly "ceases to be"

I don't personally find it irrational to beleive in a soul.

Originally posted by Storm
If they can' t be proven, then there is no rational reason to believe they would exist.

I know what you mean, but empiricism can´t be proven too since it is a tautology, yet so many people believe it is real.

I am Immortal because my soul is..

I don't know about an immortal soul, but this thread seems to be hangin' on pretty good.

According to Buddhism, there is no "me" to be immortal. You will always exist, but not as yourself.

Originally posted by Lord Urizen
According to Buddhism, there is no "me" to be immortal. You will always exist, but not as yourself.

You are not the center of your own existence. 😉

Originally posted by Shakyamunison
You are not the center of your own existence. 😉

Then what am I ? 😕

Originally posted by Lord Urizen
Then what am I ? 😕

a vessel with an undying spirit in it.

I am not immortal because my mind will die with body.

Depressing, huh?

Originally posted by FistOfThe North
a vessel with an undying spirit in it.

Exactly where inside of you is this spirit? To the right of the heart, behind the kidneys, where?

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
Exactly where inside of you is this spirit? To the right of the heart, behind the kidneys, where?

Mine is split with the Heart and Brain.

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
Exactly where inside of you is this spirit? To the right of the heart, behind the kidneys, where?

The spirit permeates the whole of one's body.

Although if we are vessels with spirits in then what is the point of a body?

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Mine is split with the Heart and Brain.
Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
The spirit permeates the whole of one's body.

If your spirit is non-physical, then how does it stay with your physical body?

Magic.

riddikulus.

Crucio.

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
If your spirit is non-physical, then how does it stay with your physical body?

Not sure...prolly the same way as my thinking and ideas and memory and etc...those are not physical...but somehow they stick to my physical brain.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Not sure...prolly the same way as my thinking and ideas and memory and etc...those are not physical...but somehow they stick to my physical brain.

The mind is an evanescent biproduct of brain functioning. That is how thoughts, memories, and ideas "stick to [your] physical brain." 🙄

I understand that...I also know that inspiration, will, thinking, and reasoning come from the same place. I wouldn't discard the idea that the soul is somewhere in the line.

And if you knew that why did you even ask me?

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
The mind is an evanescent byproduct of brain functioning. That is how thoughts, memories, and ideas "stick to [your] physical brain." 🙄

Can you prove this? You did ask for proof as to how a spirit sticks inside of someone.

So, do you have proof as to how thoughts and ideas are a byproduct of the brain's overall function, or what?