++ Really cool light effect on the background.
+ The border doesn't draw too much attention away from the action.
+ Same thing about the the text.
+ Looks high tech.
- Some blank spots.
+ I like the background, no blank spots.
+ The text blends in pretty well.
+ The render is in the center of the rings in the background and gets a bit more attention...
-- ...but that fog pretty much ruins it all.
- The darker color scheme doesn't feel right.
So, I declare Quickshot the winner in this duel.