Space M ummy
Senior Member
I can see this going to either opponent, depending on the circumstances.
Since the OP didn't really bother to lay down any specifics or ground rules, we have some wiggle room.
If this took place in a standard KMC arena, no prep time, just straight out fisticuffs- apocalypse probably loses via a speedblitz, since surfer has substantially faster speed feats. There's some evidence apocalypse can enhance his speed (he was able to surprise KO quicksilver in mid-run, so there's that) but not to lightspeed levels.
On the other hand- in character, with some prep time? Apocalypse has the resources to take this. Surfer rarely goes for an all out speedblitz to take out an opponent- look how many times he's been manhandled by Thor and Thanos- neither of whom are speedsters per se, just powerful tanks with enhanced reflexes. Don't bother counting, it's a LOT. And what is apocalypse except a powerful tank with enhanced reflexes?
Surfer has also been shown to be prone to a powerdrain- Doom has done it with his devices, and Black panther repeated the process by copying doom's designs. Apocalypse's celestial tech is at the same level if not flat out superior, AND he's shown he has equipment capable of draining Loki just laying around- no prep was necessary to pull that one off. If he can drain an Asgardian God, doing the same to a herald isn't that far off.
Apocalypse in character has a ton of resources he knows how to use, and is incredibly intelligent- if he knows an opponent has a weakness, psychological or physical, he's quick to exploit it.
Surfer in character is the exact opposite- neglecting to use the majority of the abilities he has. It's extremely unlikely we'd see surfer use the size manipulation, phasing, lightspeed assaults, planet busting shots, etc. That would make this a 10/10 fight for him.
No prep, arena battle: surfer, and by a mile.
In character battle, prep time allowed? Apocalypse takes this.