Keeping the thread on topic, none of Magneto's feats puts him anywhere near Thor. In order to prove Magneto taking it over Thor, people are going to have to bring up instances where Magneto is displaying power feats putting him in that class where Thor is not involved or other characters higher than Magneto as they are not given their full credit when the face him.
Originally posted by Rutog98
Keeping the thread on topic, none of Magneto's feats puts him anywhere near Thor. In order to prove Magneto taking it over Thor, people are going to have to bring up instances where Magneto is displaying power feats putting him in that class where Thor is not involved or other characters higher than Magneto as they are not given their full credit when the face him.
Why do you think they are not given their full credit when facing Magneto?
Originally posted by masterbruceI guess you didn't read the story where Galactus was absorbing the universe before he stopped himself, then?
That F&*&K*N BULLSHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!A universe is comprised of billions of stars, even 1/5 would be millions of stars.
A blast that could destroy 1/5th of a universe would mean it would take out millions of stars, something even Galactus shouldn't be able to withstand.
If you believe Thor could absorb something like that, than I give up.
Originally posted by masterbruce😐
that blast that he used on Galactus wasn't a planet destroying blast, he didn't even focus much energy into it.
Originally posted by bigbran
I guess you didn't read the story where Galactus was absorbing the universe before he stopped himself, then?😐
Anyway... Thanos has destroyed a planet in his first appearance, or something like that.
He is way more powerful than he was in his first appearance.
look, I just HATE inconsistency, but for the most part I can tolerate it.
However, if Thor can absorb a blast of universal proportions, than he should NEVER struggle with any earth villains. I personally think that Thor absorbing a universe destroying blast is PIS, as I don't think he is meant as that powerful of a character...I don't think anyone less than a top level celestial should even be able to absorb something of that magnitude.
Originally posted by masterbruceI agree with the pis part.
look, I just HATE inconsistency, but for the most part I can tolerate it.However, if Thor can absorb a blast of universal proportions, than he should NEVER struggle with any earth villains. I personally think that Thor absorbing a universe destroying blast is PIS, as I don't think he is meant as that powerful of a character...I don't think anyone less than a top level celestial should even be able to absorb something of that magnitude.
Originally posted by masterbruce
I mean accept it as truth.Spiderman beat Firelord on panel too, is he now a herald level???
Thor and Mjolnir would both be cosmic dust if they tried to absorb a blast that could wipe out any portion of a universe.
No.
How would they be cosmic dust if they have already successfully completed the feat? PIS can be called on it, but it doesn't change the fact that it happened.
Thor is the occasional victim of "team syndrome" where everyone on a team, regardless of how powerful, jobs to make a villian look sweet.
But Thor has absorbed Mag's shield out from under him before (I'll post the scan if I need to, but it's posted a couple times in the respect thread), and has much higher feats.
P.S. If you hate inconsistency, stop reading comics. Seriously. It's that inconsistency that gives us sh*t to talk about on this forum.
There are two incidents being thrown about here.
The first is the incident from the Black Galaxy Saga, circa Thor 420 or so.
Without giving away the details of the Black Galaxy Saga(its one of the most important in Marvel Cosmic continuity), someone wanted to destroy the Black Galaxy. They made a Null Bomb. The bomb detonated but Thor (using Mjollnir)
a) absorbed the energy
b) perceived hundreds of billions of light years away in another galaxy that the star that some random civilization was orbiting was dying
c) sent said energy across hundreds of billions of lightyears
d) used it to restore the star to its older, higher level output
The second incident is the Incident from an Avengers annual, 16 IIRC.
In that the Grandmaster, for some plot based reason, wanted to blow up the universe. He made 5 Nega Bombs (IIRC this is what they were called). Each would destroy 1/5 of the universe. One in fact did go off and blow up 1/5 of the universe (it must not have been an important part).
I don't recall what happened to the other 3, but they did not go off. The 5th one did. Thor created a forcefield which contained the blast and then IIRC shunted the energy into another dimension.
As to Thor vs Magneto, as someone mentioned above, Thor has owned him in the past, including an incident where he depowered him.
Thor would kill Magneto in seconds here.