Team 1 easily. Nightcrawler is what seals the deal. At the moment Cap says hike Kurt just teleports to take a direct snap then teleports to the end zone (which are both in his line of site) instantly and scores everytime.
Also, Bullseye wouldn't complete a single pass because Nightcrawler would be able to teleport directly to the ball in mid air and do his best Deion Sanders impersonation everytime.
Remove Nightcrawler and add DareDevil to make it even. The teleportation makes this very lopsided.
Nah, that's why there's this thing called the "shotgun formation" in football. Cap doesn't have to be under center to receive the ball. It's very onesided with Nightcrawler on the team. He can easily teleport to 2 points in his line of sight in less than a second.
It's pretty much hike-bamf-bamf-touchdown.