Better Vigilante The Punisher Or Batman?

Started by qqqqqqq2 pages

is the fighter judge?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
I wonder how he will respond to meeting Fighter . . .

Fighter?

Originally posted by SpunkySmurph
You know, neither of these two are technically vigilantes...

vig·i·lan·te

n.

One who takes or advocates the taking of law enforcement into one's own hands.

dur

Originally posted by Badabing
vig·i·lan·te

n.

One who takes or advocates the taking of law enforcement into one's own hands.

dur

Bruce

Bruce is better in pretty much every way....

But...

When the Punisher catches someone, there is no Arkham break-out. Someone caught by the Punisher stays caught.

Originally posted by Soljer
Bruce is better in pretty much every way....

But...

When the Punisher catches someone, there is no Arkham break-out. Someone caught by the Punisher stays caught.

Sidious likes Castle also. Bruce Wayne wins. Meh

Originally posted by Soljer
Bruce is better in pretty much every way....

But...

When the Punisher catches someone, there is no Arkham break-out. Someone caught by the Punisher stays caught.

They don't stay anything except dead.

What happens in the instance that someone is wrongly accused. At least if Bruce catches someone and places them in Arkhma if they're guilty they can be released but what can Frank do after he's blown someone's head off?

"Oops"

I'm going with Batman.

He has a stronger moral sense and better gadgets.

Originally posted by marvelprince
They don't stay anything except dead.

What happens in the instance that someone is wrongly accused. At least if Bruce catches someone and places them in Arkhma if they're guilty they can be released but what can Frank do after he's blown someone's head off?

"Oops"

Furthermore I dont think all criminals are neccesarily bad people. No im not saying its good to break the law but sometimes people get caught up in crime without meaning to.

I can understand why Frank does what he does but he is a bit shallow, thinking all criminals are scum.

Technically only batman is enforceing the Law with his own hands because he turns them in for trial. Where as punisher is discarding the law, saying that basicly, they might do bad things they should die the end.

Originally posted by marvelprince
They don't stay anything except dead.

What happens in the instance that someone is wrongly accused. At least if Bruce catches someone and places them in Arkhma if they're guilty they can be released but what can Frank do after he's blown someone's head off?

"Oops"

By caught - I was implying their death.

Oh, and vigilante justice takes that risk. Batman may be the better superhero, and he may be the better fighter, thinker, etc.

But Castle's the better Vigilante.

Let's compare the two of them:

Batman is a cool guy, who takes is time to be sure that he gets the bad guy. He's not acting with the law, but he respect it. He's not killing anybody, prefering let the society judging them.

The Punisher, however, is the number one bad ass of comic books. Don't bother with the thing "Are they good or not!?". He shoots, and take an another call.

I'd say it's a draw: Batman is better, but Punisher, I'm 100% sure, Kills alot more criminals that Batman did.

Punisher vs suspicious looking Jaywalker BLAM!

Bats vs jaywalker "heynow is that a rolled up magazine or arya just pleased to see me?"