Hercules vs Beta Ray bill

Started by Soljer3 pages

Does anyone see Thor in this thread? No?

Take it somewhere else, guys.

Thor and Bill are equals. No more. No less.

Bill is often more 'to the point' than Thor - but that is of little consequence in most forum battles. And in a forum battle, Bill vs. Thor would likely end up as 5/10. Nothing else.

Take it to another thread, c'mon!

Originally posted by Soljer
Does anyone see Thor in this thread? No?

Take it somewhere else, guys.

Thor and Bill are equals. No more. No less.

Bill is often more 'to the point' than Thor - but that is of little consequence in most forum battles. And in a forum battle, Bill vs. Thor would likely end up as 5/10. Nothing else.

Take it to another thread, c'mon!

My bad, I was just pointing out that Bill have never out right defeated Thor in a fair and neutral battle.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
My bad, I was just pointing out that Bill have never out right defeated Thor in a fair and neutral battle.

I understand, you believe that you were clearing up a bit of misinformation. Howard thought otherwise. Disagreement. Debate.

Got it.

It's just that there's a time and a place, and though any time may be suitable, this thread is not the place.

Hercules edges Bill out by a margin in those conditions.

And all the three (Thor/Bill/Herc) are really close. Altho i probably see Thor as the best figther of the two (between him and BRB). If memory serves hes bested Bill more times than Bill bested him.

Hercules is the best fighter here and should win most of the fights

Hercules 7/10

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Hercules 7/10

I'm not so sure. I think you're underrating Bill to try to somehow build up Thor.

I mean, it's a fist fight, but regardless. Do you think that Herc would take THOR seven out of ten in a fist fight?

If I gave Hercules a majority, it'd be a slight one. Closer to six or even five and a half out of ten. Against either of the hammer brothers, that is.

Originally posted by Soljer
I'm not so sure. I think you're underrating Bill to try to somehow build up Thor.

I mean, it's a fist fight, but regardless. Do you think that Herc would take THOR seven out of ten in a fist fight?

If I gave Hercules a majority, it'd be a slight one. Closer to six or even five and a half out of ten. Against either of the hammer brothers, that is.

I like Thor and Bill equally as much, not trying to build up anyone.

Na, but Hercules takes 7/10 on BRB in a strait h2h match because of his massive skill and experience advantage.

Most times when Herc and Thor battle it's because herc edges Thor slightly in the skill department. Now when fighting a nearly exact replica with less skill, and experience, I think it's clear that Herc takes the clear majority.

But meh 6/10 Herc is fine by me.

And why exactly do you give Thor the skill advantage over Bill?

Skill with Mjolnir(Stormbreaker)'s powers, sure. But hand to hand skill? Where is the justification for that? Most people see Bill as a slightly more skilled combatant than Thor.

Originally posted by Soljer
And why exactly do you give Thor the skill advantage over Bill?

Skill with Mjolnir(Stormbreaker)'s powers, sure. But hand to hand skill? Where is the justification for that? Most people see Bill as a slightly more skilled combatant than Thor.

While Thor has been trained in the art of was for thousands upon thousands of years, Bill has not. Thor being a superbly skilled warrior, and highly proficient in hand-to-hand combat, should be more skilled than The Cyborg who was first created as a guardian. Now don't get me wrong, Bill is skilled just not as much as a warrior god.

I would also give Herc the edge in H2H over Bill. I don't believe Thor ever admitted Bill to be superior to him in that area.

herc 6-7/10 imo.