Master Windu V Naga Sadow?

Originally posted by General Kenobl
[B]Yes, we can't quantify the brick's speed. But it's definately not at the speed of light, or even as fast as the speed of a bullet.

Please, tell me how they have heads harder than several times a human skull? I am not positive Ludo Kressh is human, but he is definately a humanoid and probably posesses most of human anatomy. So tell me, unless he has natural head armor, how the hell would he have survived that brick if came down as a plummeting missile? I mean, his head wasn't even at least a bit splattered and in one picture he only has minimal blood on his face.

Darth Bandon was supposedly the strongest among all the Sith during the Jedi Civil War for Malak. Yet, he's not more powerful than Darth Maul. The fact that he was a strong candidate for DLOTS among those thousand might be some a boost, but not a definite sign of strength.

The good ol' Traya >>>> DE Sidious, Vader < dirt, and Revan > NJO Luke days... can't say I miss them.

Anyway, when has Sadow shown any great (and they would need to be great if you hope for him to even compete with Windu) abilities that would help him in personal combat? Throwing a brick? It's just not enough.
Sure he was one of the top dogs of his time and order (as was Mace), but, realistically, his order has nothing over the PT, a big part of this is speed with lightsabers, as opposed to heavy swords. Better technology and more advanced combat practices help a lot in melee. This isn't to say that he would get beat by any one just because they are a PT Jedi. Like you said, his knowledge and being one of the most powerful of his time does count for something, but, to put him against the likes of Mace is just a losing battle.

I'm just going to ROFL at this, I like it, too.

When I meant "strong candidate for DLOTS" I WAS TALKING ABOUT NAGA SADOW, NOT BANDON!!!

Well gee we used to have ancient sith fanboyism, now its PT Jedi fanboyism.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Well gee we used to have ancient sith fanboyism, now its PT Jedi fanboyism.

Yoda has been proved, with solid evidence, to be the strongest Jedi up until that point. Then you have people that are on par or close to him, like Sidious (who has been proved to be the most powerful Sith, over and over), Mace, Dooku, and Anakin. They have some of the most powerful individuals ever, with quotes to back it up, so I wouldn't call it fanboyism. They were just the "Golden Age of the Jedi," with quite a few very powerful individuals. I mean, if a few above average people from the PT (Agen, Seasse, and Kit) were described as some of the best swordsmen the order had ever produced, the PT definitely has something going for it.

Yea but I also see blatant anti KOTOR/GAOTS rhetoric on this forum. There are only a few people here who judge objectively.

Originally posted by General Kenobl
When I meant "strong candidate for DLOTS" I WAS TALKING ABOUT NAGA SADOW, NOT BANDON!!!

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Yea but I also see blatant anti KOTOR/GAOTS rhetoric on this forum. There are only a few people here who judge objectively.

True. There is a lot of spite out there, but, regardless of what they think, what do you think of this fight? Do you agree with what I said, or is there something wrong about it?

ROFLcopter

soi soi soi soi.

Originally posted by Advent
soi soi soi soi.

Do you?

Originally posted by Advent
Do you?

Yea but I also see blatant anti KOTOR/GAOTS rhetoric on this forum. There are only a few people here who judge objectively.

There's not that much anti KOTOR as it was anti PT and pro Ancient Sith.

Naga Sadow:

- Strong Contender for the Dark Lord of the Sith Position after Marka Ragnos's death

- Was winning in his duel for the position of DLOTS against Ludo Kressh

- Was compared to the likes of Revan in PoD

- Even after death, his powerful spirit helped Freedon Nadd walk into darkness

However, compare these to Mace's feats, it simply does not make Sadow greater than Windu.

Maybe not, but Mace's "vaapad" and shatterpoint don't make him greater than Sadow either. It goes both ways. Look at how strong Kun became after learning from Sadow's teachings. That should say something.

Kun learned from Freedon Nadd , not Naga Sadow. Nadd learned from Sadow .

Originally posted by General Kenobl
Kun learned from [B]Freedon Nadd , not Naga Sadow. Nadd learned from Sadow . [/B]

Oh sorry, my bad.

Darth Bandon was supposedly the strongest among all the Sith during the Jedi Civil War for Malak. Yet, he's not more powerful than Darth Maul. The fact that he was a strong candidate for DLOTS among those thousand might be some a boost, but not a definite sign of strength.

I don't think he would pwn Naga either, but I do think he'd beat Naga.

True, good point, but Bandon wasn't even second strongest, Traya, Nihilus and Sion were all ahead of him. At best he was Fifth strongest. I dunno, I just don't think Mace would pwn Naga.

Well obviously, but they weren't directly involved in the fighting, were they? I mean otherwise Malak would have had competition and he would chosen someone like Sion for an apprentice.

I don't believe Mace pwns Naga, he just wins.