What's the Greater Injustice ?

What angers you more ?

A Guilty Person NOT being Punished

or

An Innocent Person being Punished

?

Innocent punished.

The guilty guy will get what's coming to him sooner or later.

Innocent being punished...

Especially if they know he or she wasn't guilty.

An Innocent Person being Punished.

So far we all agree......

I also thnk it is far worse for an innocent person to be punished

Depends what the crime was I'd rather have an innocent fined for petty theft than a murderer set free.

Originally posted by quickshot
Depends what the crime was I'd rather have an innocent fined for petty theft than a murderer set free.

Not really comparable. What would you rather have a murderer free or somebody in jail for murder when he didn't do it?

The guilty will meet justice when they die.

innocent person being punished it far worse

I think they're both the same to me.

Originally posted by Lord Urizen
So far we all agree......

Because the question was a no-brainer.

If an innocent person is being punished, then by extension, a guilty person is not being punished.

Yep.

Originally posted by Quiero Mota
Because the question was a no-brainer.

You'd be surprised...there are some people who'd be willing to risk sending an innocent person to the death penalty, in effort to prevent a crime.

I will not mention who I am talking about, but myself and a few other people had a debate with a certain someone who argued his extreme hate for peadophiles, and how he'd be willing to kill a man who might be innocent in effort to prevent children from being molested in the future.

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
If an innocent person is being punished, then by extension, a guilty person is not being punished.

Not necessarily always the case... What if a person is being wrongfully punished by an imagined or false crime?

i think that this is an open shut case........... an innocent being punished.

Cause guilty people go free LOTS of times.

Originally posted by Robtard
Not necessarily always the case... What if a person is being wrongfully punished by an imagined or false crime?

An imagined or false crime has an imagined or false criminal.

Therefore, if an innocent person is being punished for an imaginary crime, then by extension, an imaginary guilty person is not being punished.

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
An imagined or false crime has an imagined or false criminal.

Therefore, if an innocent person is being punished for an imaginary crime, then by extension, an imaginary guilty person is not being punished.

Thats very . . . Alice in Wonerland

What happens if an imaginary innocent person is puinshed by an imaginary court to an imaginary death penalty?

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
Thats very . . . Alice in Wonerland

What happens if an imaginary innocent person is puinshed by an imaginary court to an imaginary death penalty?

😆

I'd rather an imaginary innocent person not have an imaginary punishment than for an imaginary criminal to get away with imaginary freedom

Originally posted by Lord Urizen
😆

I'd rather an imaginary innocent person not have an imaginary punishment than for an imaginary criminal to get away with imaginary freedom

AWESOME