Dan Didio vs. Joe Quesada

Originally posted by Validus
Fuggin hell, this thread is retarded. Neither of these guys deserve any sort of pat on the back.

52 is totally the brainchild of Grant Morrison. His writing style is all over that book.

Your right. Infinite Crisis = Geoff, 52 = Grant.

Credit to Didio for giving them creative freedom

Originally posted by marvelprince
Your right. Infinite Crisis = Geoff, 52 = Grant.

Credit to Didio for giving them creative freedom

i don't think any one person had creative freedom with IC, i really don't...

Dididio is sadly better then Quesada. Quesada's a bigger idiot than Dididio

what if oprah ran marvel...

Originally posted by Validus

52 is totally the brainchild of Grant Morrison. His writing style is all over that book.

Not really, its not filled with confusing artsy and symbolic storytelling like Morrison usually does

Man I hate Morrison sometimes 😐

Originally posted by Redatom65
what if oprah ran marvel...

She'd make writing deals with authors who've written lies about their past. 😛

Originally posted by Grimm22
Not really, its not filled with confusing artsy and symbolic storytelling like Morrison usually does

Man I hate Morrison sometimes 😐

Originally posted by pr1983
i don't think any one person had creative freedom with IC, i really don't...

Originally posted by Validus
Morrison only does that with his Indy stuff.

Geoff Johns saved Nightwing from Didio's idiocy, buddy.

him and public opinion wasnt it? 😛

i meant though in the sense that didio didnt just say to johns 'we need a new crisis, do seven issues and come back to me when you're ready'

Originally posted by pr1983
him and public opinion wasnt it? 😛

i meant though in the sense that didio didnt just say to johns 'we need a new crisis, do seven issues and come back to me when you're ready'

Originally posted by Validus
Yeah but nobody is going to get that kind of freedom.

obviously... 😛

unfortunately... imagine giving someone like johns or busiek or morrison to do a crisis the way they want to...

the results would be interesting to say the least...

Originally posted by pr1983
i don't think any one person had creative freedom with IC, i really don't...

I didn't mean that he basically went to Johns and said hey we need a big event, make it happen. I meant that he made sure John's was very involved and had a lot to say about the matter. I think it says alot that he gave the guy editor status in order to co-ordinate the whole thing.

joe quesada, i like them both i just like quesada better

Originally posted by marvelprince
I didn't mean that he basically went to Johns and said hey we need a big event, make it happen. I meant that he made sure John's was very involved and had a lot to say about the matter. I think it says alot that he gave the guy editor status in order to co-ordinate the whole thing.

i think though if didio and a few others had taken more of a backseat, we would have had a better event...

Originally posted by marvelprince

On the other hand a lot of editoral decisions I've not agreed with. Bringing back the multiverse? So soon? I still fail to see the point. Maybe if they'd gone ahead and killed Nightwing too.

Well, I'm really looking forward to see what really happens after the multiverse.

One reason I started to like Dan is because he's been doing this lately in Comic Book conventions.

YouTube video

I was a Wizard World Los Angeles last Saturday. I was way back in line waiting for the DC pannel....lord and behold there he was....No one recognize him (that goatee and hat threw us off). But I like what he is doing...listening to the fans and talking with them. Sneaky, but I like it. 🙂

I like Didio. At wizard world chicago last year he was walking around and gave me and my friend "52" posters that were autographed by Geoff Johns just because we were wearing DC Nation pins.

This was funny. 😂

Right now, we have the Skrull paranoia at Marvel, versus the Amazons Attack event at DC. Because AA is such crap (even Draco69 thinks so), Quesada has the edge, at this time.
We'll see how much Marvel tries to retcon with the Skrulls. Check in later...

Didio.

Originally posted by roughrider
Right now, we have the Skrull paranoia at Marvel, versus the Amazons Attack event at DC. Because AA is such crap (even Draco69 thinks so), Quesada has the edge, at this time.
We'll see how much Marvel tries to retcon with the Skrulls. Check in later...

Neither the Skrull thing or Amazons Attack are the events worth following in their respective company. For Marvel its WWH and DC its Sinestro Corp.

Originally posted by Validus
What a lame comparison.

Neither the Skrull thing or Amazons Attack are the events worth following in their respective company. For Marvel its WWH and DC its Sinestro Corp.

Yeah, well I'm just using them for comparison, as sub-par events go.