The Core
AmStar 14 Manager
Originally posted by manorastroman
you don't know very much about punk history, do you? first of all, punk wasn't initially political at all. it was in fact anti-politics, and completely apathetic. and the ramones were a far cry from nice, excluding joey. they didn't dress the part? are you ****ing with me? they are the prototype punk aesthetic. tight jeans, old shirts, leather jackets, dirty, messy hair. think about it.without the ramones, punk would have no speed. they were the band that decided to bash through thirty songs in fifty minutes. by extension, hardcore is very fundamentally indebted to the ramones.
the ramones were the original harbingers of punk. deal with it.
suggested reading: please kill me, by legs mcneil. in case you were unawares, legs was a founder of PUNK magazine. you know. the magazine that coined PUNK, and essentially documented the entire four-year punk run?
Anti. Pro. Politics were at the root, I thought that was already implied. The Ramones "uniform" was more "slob" cum 50's greaser than anything. When you say punk. I think spiky, colored hair and trashy clothes. Not torn jeans, unkept locks, and leather jackets. I tend to think The Ramones songs were short because you can only write so much nonsense about being bored. Sorry if that sounds insensitive, but it's true. They made "punk" for people who didn't want to commit to the lifestyle. Punk, the term actually coined by Dave Marsh of Creem magazine in '70. You can Wiki that if you don't believe me.
The Ramones were a glorified, grungy version of The Beach Boys.
Originally posted by manorastroman
do you loathe it unconditionally? because in some circumstances, it's a popular opinion because it's "true", insofar as opinions can be.stop revealing your ignorance. they didn't play follow the leader in the least. they were the leaders. read up on the subject. and they barely got radio play during their career, and certainly never the first three years.
also i'm fairly sure they never struck it rich, by conventional standards. in fact...what the hell are you talking about?
Popular opinion is still an opinion, and 1/2 of the people's input is baseless or uneducated. The Ramones being a "punk" band, a good example. They got lucky, sharing NONE of the characteristics of the true punk bands, other than fast guitars and drums.
Not much else I can say other than The Ramones, in theory, were not a punk band. Wether it defies popular opinion or not. It's educated opinion that prevails in the end, not predisposition by what you've been told all your life, or so convinced of.
They were influential. They were a band. Just one of the rock n' roll variety.