Thorinn vs. Barker

Originally posted by Kenshiro Yuki
The judge is running late....
Yes... Yes... I know I'm being a bit of a procrastinator right now.
I had to get through 50 pages of the history of computers for my tech class today....

[b]Thorinn:

++ Blending
++ Colors
+ Text
+ The use of the Liquify option (I am guessing that the squigley lines were created using Liquify, is my guess correct?)
+ Most of render used
= The effect you used on the background isn't a favorite, but it works
- Font and text could have been centered on the blade a bit more
- Border

Barker:

++Lighting: it seems almost like a summoning
++ Blending
+ Background
+ The ring of "text"
+ Border
+ Most of render used
- Greenish cloud don't quite match the render

Very close duel. I found the entries quite hard to judge, and perhaps that is my fault - I shouldn't have given you so much space to work with. I envy both of you, and might I say that in my mind both of you are in the top 10 signature makers on this forum. It was a pleasure to judge this duel, and I apologize for being late.

And now to announce the winner:
After much debating, I have come to this conclusion. While both of you did an excelent job and your entries stunned me, Bark won me over with his magical lighting and background combination. Therefore,

Barker is the winner. [/B]

Originally posted by BakaXero
makes me wonder who else is in that list hmm

My guess is about eight other people. hmm

I went over the KB limit, I just realized. Thorinn wins. sly

I knew it. sly

Originally posted by Thorinn
Where's the judge?

whos face is in he hood barker?

Originally posted by Barker
I went over the KB limit, I just realized. Thorinn wins. sly

EDIT: I guess Thorinn is the official winner then.