Rewmac's and Kallark's Sig Contest First Round

I'll bow out with Marko if SC and DC show up

[EDIT]If not why not let Eclipso,Me and Marko go through but eliminate 3.

The problem is the original idea was 4 goes out , out of 12. Now we only have 10 entries and 3 people...Instead of 8, only 7 are going to the next round and not because "how they make sigs" only because they haven't paid attention to the rules.

Sorry, I just hate small sigs like that, Why did you make them so small in the first place?

Originally posted by Eclipso
Sorry, I just hate small sigs like that, Why did you make them so small in the first place?

Originally posted by BakaXero
that excuse does not help the fact that you failed to read the criteria... you need to be careful if you want to be in with a chance. 😬

I might not, I'm not sure I can make a sig that small.

Originally posted by Eclipso
I might not, I'm not sure I can make a sig that small.

No I just prefer a larger sized sig, I can do more with it. To each his own.

Originally posted by Eclipso
No I just prefer a larger sized sig, I can do more with it. To each his own.

Meh, If it's that big of a thing then I'll just withdraw.

Originally posted by Eclipso
Meh, If it's that big of a thing then I'll just withdraw.

Originally posted by ThePittman
It's not a big thing but just saying that I like to work big because you can do more with it is very limiting and I was just pointing out that it is not. To take an example with your current sig you could put it into the same size requirements as this duel and would still have the same quality and in my opinion would be a better design. The extra width on this image I think is a waste of space and would give more impact if it were reduced.

To each his own.

So are we out or not?

Rewmac has the final decision

Marko, Eclipso, quickshot: Rewmac has the final decision. I'm sure his decision will be based on what is best for the tournament structure. If he accepts you, you're in the next round, regardless.

Originally posted by Eclipso
To each his own.

That may be your personal opinon, but you have no grounds on which to break the rules.

Criterias are there to challenge you, to make you work with material you normally don't work with in a style you normally don't. I'm sure Rewmac has some challenging criterias ahead. It is not your place to disregard a judges rules. Your goal is to create the best sig within the given limits.

I think Eclipso made the sig the size it was in ful knowledge of the criteria. Me and marko just made a mistake

I'll would gladly let you in, but in that case we go another round...
To stick to the strickt rules I'd say you are out...
I don't want this to be any kind of personal thing, but if anybody else would have made the sig bigger we wouldn't let them go on...
It was a clear criteria...
Sorry guys

We go on with 7 constesters.

I say they are out. That's just one vote.

There is still Lana, Juggs66666 and Pittman to say clearly what they think...

Originally posted by Rewmac
I'll would gladly let you in, but in that case we go another round...
To stick to the strickt rules I'd say you are out...
I don't want this to be any kind of personal thing, but if anybody else would have made the sig bigger we wouldn't let them go on...
It was a clear criteria...
Sorry guys

We go on with 7 constesters.

I say they are out. That's just one vote.

There is still Lana, Juggs66666 and Pittman to say clearly what they think...

cool thats okay with me 😄

Originally posted by Rewmac
I'll would gladly let you in, but in that case we go another round...
To stick to the strickt rules I'd say you are out...
I don't want this to be any kind of personal thing, but if anybody else would have made the sig bigger we wouldn't let them go on...
It was a clear criteria...
Sorry guys

We go on with 7 constesters.

I say they are out. That's just one vote.

There is still Lana, Juggs66666 and Pittman to say clearly what they think...

Doesn't matter to me either way.

in by default t00w

good thing too... cause i had no chance ermm