ROTS Sidious vs ROTS Anakin

Well, seeing as all the mixed opinions about the Lucas quote, I'm making this thread just for people to say what they think. I'm probably gonna keep myself out of this one, to busy at the moment!

Damn, saw this one just a little more below! Oh well, guess this one makes a fresh start about the quote thing! And 1 + score for my posts....

Happy Birthday Rampant Ox!!!!!!! 😄

Anakin could possibly take this if he remnains completely calm and focused. If not then Yoda wins. Overall I'd put my money on Yoda 8/10.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Anakin could possibly take this if he remnains completely calm and focused. If not then Yoda wins. Overall I'd put my money on Yoda 8/10.

Huh?

Anakin is better with a lightsaber, while Yoda is a lot better with Force powers and thus overall and isn't this Anakin versus Sidious?

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Anakin is better with a lightsaber, while Yoda is a lot better with Force powers and thus overall and isn't this Anakin versus Sidious?

was about to point this out 😉

Originally posted by darthsith19
Anakin could possibly take this if he remnains completely calm and focused. If not then Yoda wins. Overall I'd put my money on Yoda 8/10.

Wuteva man, gimme some of whatever that shit is. *inhales deeply* Oh shit son! Yoda's gonna pwn R2!

Wha-? I swear this said Yoda! Whatever, though, my verdict still stands. But with Sidious replacing Yoda.

Originally posted by kamikz
Happy Birthday Rampant Ox!!!!!!! 😄

Cheers. 😄

I don't see Anakin having any chance of defeating Sidious. He lost to Obi-wan, who got raped by Dooku, Sidious' inferior. I'd like to quote LS on the issue, "Actually, Lucas says only Mace and Yoda can compete with Palpatine. Period.

Anakin is not them."

but anakin pwned Dooku, so there goes that theroy out the window.

Too bad for the idea that Anakin pwned Dooku is the fact that Sidious had instructed Dooku to lose. Dooku was to let Anakin capture him.

He had never been instructed to lose. He was told that it was a test, and that if Anakin somehow got the better of him Sidious would interfere. Although it is true that Dooku was never meant to kill Anakin, which might have been the point you were trying to make.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Too bad for the idea that Anakin pwned Dooku is the fact that Sidious had instructed Dooku to lose. Dooku was to let Anakin capture him.

What the- ?

Glenctract I never would have expected something like that from you!

i seem to recall "fighting for his life", and "treat it as my crowning achievement". It's been settled that Anakin won fairly, due to being superior. There's absolutely no point in "testing" someone and not giving it your all. If you believe the contrary to be true, you're an idiot.

By the way, prove to me that Dooku was to let Anakin capture him.

Read the ROTS novel. I can post some quotes from it tomorrow but I won't be able to get to it tonight. In it Dooku was thinking about the plan Sidious had come up with that had him killing Obi-wan and then faking a loss to Anakin. The test by Sidious on Anakin was not to see if he was strong enough to defeat Dooku, but to see if he was strong enough to kill an unarmed prisoner; a Dark Side thing no matter how you look at it.

You also remember how Dooku realized Anakin was too powerful for him and Palpatine promised to intervene if Dooku's life was in danger?

Anakin won that fair and square

Anakin by the time of ROTS was the best lightsaber dualist ever, up until that point, but Dooku still had better Force powers.
Sidious can easily defeat Anakin, like in the place like the Senate, but if Anakin can force a lightsaber duel in a close room, with no objects to throw for Sidious, Anakin has a god chance of wining.

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Anakin by the time of ROTS was the best lightsaber dualist ever, up until that point, but Dooku still had better Force powers.

Originally posted by Count Makashi

Sidious can easily defeat Anakin, like in the place like the Senate, but if Anakin can force a lightsaber duel in a close room, with no objects to throw for Sidious, Anakin has a god chance of wining.

In a saber battle, Anakin easily takes it.