Boobsmagee vs IceJaw

Originally posted by Eclipso
I gave you two options, plus if your a good sig maker, the render shouldn't be much of a factor.

Again no offence but just look in your other threads.

Originally posted by Eclipso
plus if your a good sig maker, the render shouldn't be much of a factor.

EDIT: not to mention I totally forgot about this duel.

Well it's not, in many types of competition you don't get to choose your material. (Example: a singing competition, you don't always get to choose your song) As I said I would never turn down a render. A true talent is someone who can take anything and make it great.

Yes I choose different renders, cause I'm tired of seeing the same or same type of render used over and over again. And it's useually some army one which I say now to people I will never ever pick as a render cause I think it's a boring thing to make a sig of. Versatility is a good quality to develop.

And yes I believe you about how much you put into the sig and also no offence but thats why you lost the duel.

Originally posted by Eclipso
Well it's not, in many types of competition you don't get to choose your material. (Example: a singing competition, you don't always get to choose your song) As I said I would never turn down a render. A true talent is someone who can take anything and make it great.

Originally posted by Eclipso
And yes I believe you about how much you put into the sig and also no offence but thats why you lost the duel.

request a close much?

Please?

No need for all of this. Its obvious you have different views and that your just going to aannoy each other like this so close?

Originally posted by Marko
request a close much?

Please?

No need for all of this. Its obvious you have different views and that your just going to aannoy each other like this so close?

They'll probably just fight in their own threads.

I side with Ice on this one.You can't make a decent sig with a bad render.

Okey, let me tell you a story of my duels.

You know what kind of renders I acutally got?!?!

Mutated donald duck with octopus fins.
Yoshi
Gay anime dude.

I'm seriously starting to get sick of people giving retarded renders. However, I didn't find Eclipse's render to be bad...

Originally posted by Help
They'll probably just fight in their own threads.

I side with Ice on this one.You can't make a decent sig with a bad render.

1) First off it's not a bad render, but even if someone gave me a bad render I would make the best sig I could for it and find a way to use it. Only a lack of talent prevents this.

2) It's a picture of a demon, explain how it doesn't fit a "hell" theme?

Originally posted by Eclipso
1) First off it's not a bad render, but even if someone gave me a bad render I would make the best sig I could for it and find a way to use it. Only a lack of talent prevents this.

It is a bad render they have no flow, the demon guys got no legs and and did you just call me and Ice talentless?

Well, the coloring of the render is hard to blend in... Make the background and brushes black, then it wouldn't be noticible, make it white and it would be way to light for the render...

Originally posted by Help
and and did you just call me and Ice talentless?

*cough*Big misstake*cough*

Boobs managed to do something with it.

And I never said you guys were talentless. Only that if you are prevented from making a quality sig becuase you didn't like the render, then your talent only extends so far.

IceJaw you lost, and it was a pretty sound defeat. Sorry if you can't handle that.

Stop bitching about the decision of a judge on an online forum and move on with your young lives?

Whatever. It's not even about that.

Originally posted by Eclipso
IceJaw you lost, and it was a pretty sound defeat. Sorry if you can't handle that.

Maybe we should solve this with a peacefull match of Tic Tac To?

I was thinking a team duel?

Originally posted by Help
I was thinking a team duel?

Guys, you could give me a pic of a stick figure and I would still make the best sig I possibly could and I wouldn't whine about it once.

So if you can only win a deul when it's your own handpicked sig then it reflects poorly on your ability.

Again, you act like your own opinion is a fact.

wtf i dont get why this got blown so far out of porportion, IVE SEEN ALOT WORSE RENDERS released in duels, so the fact that it went sof ar with this one is blowing my mind, i know i wasnt totally happy with a hell theme, but who cares, really its about having fun, so dont ***** all the time, my god, yah i partially agree with u jaw, and eclipso, a bad render makes a bad sig, but im not sure that applies to this case, bcuz icejaw made an amazing sig, just not fully based around the theme, so why the hell are we fighting about this?

had to go didnt get time to finish what i was going for but

he technically didnt say u guys are bad artists, first of all quickshot this really has nothing to do with u tho i respect you as an artist, and he was makinga valid point a good sig artist can usually make a good sig outta a bad render, its been done and is done, so a good artist wouldn tcomplain about a bad render, and u can consider his render bad which it really wasnt, but consider the fact that u acutally made something good out of it so in ways u cna almost say u are being complemented, just give htis up

theres no reason for you to fight about something as petty as this

all it does is to make you all look like fools

I'll quit as soon as he quits BSing about how talent is related to supplied renders.