Ok, I just want to go on the record before the final book comes out and state that I fully believe the "Harry is a Horcrux" theory. It just makes sense to me. There seems to be a lot of evidence for it and I think that a lot of assumptions made by characters in the book can be taken as misdirection. Afterall, Dumbledore himself said that being as smart as he is, his accidents tend to be somewhat colossal.
Originally posted by The Phantom
Do you people still think Harry can be one now? It wasn't intentional, as it should have been if it was to make a horcrux.
But thats just Dumbldore's opinion. Who says that that he knows exactly what Voldemort's motivation was?
He himself said that after the first couple of memories they viewed, Voldemort's plans and actions were unknown, and could only be speculated on.
I have a baby theory that it's Godric Gryffindor's sword - that that's the thing Dumbledore was wrong about. I dunno, I just like the irony of that. I know that he probably would have sensed the evil magickness of a Horcrux in the office after all that time, but I just LOVE the possibility of Harry searching and searching, and having it be the thing that was under his nose the whole time. That would be so cool.
It would be so... JK like.
🙂
I think that there is no way Harry could be a horcrux. A horcrux is meant to be something that can't die. Voldemort wouldn't have wanted to rely on Harry staying alive. Eventually Harry will die, even if it's old age. That is why living things aren't good horcruxes. Here's a crazy idea though. What about Fawkes? Dumbledore's Phoneix? A phoenix dies and then is reborn from the ashes. It would be a unique horcrux. I am just trying to think of other things that Voldemort might have used as a horcrux. I think whatever it is, JK would want to keep us guessing until the end.
Originally posted by phoenixtears101o.o Just answer this. How would Voldemort get a hold of Fawkes?
I think that there is no way Harry could be a horcrux. A horcrux is meant to be something that can't die. Voldemort wouldn't have wanted to rely on Harry staying alive. Eventually Harry will die, even if it's old age. That is why living things aren't good horcruxes. Here's a crazy idea though. What about Fawkes? Dumbledore's Phoneix? A phoenix dies and then is reborn from the ashes. It would be a unique horcrux. I am just trying to think of other things that Voldemort might have used as a horcrux. I think whatever it is, JK would want to keep us guessing until the end.