Originally posted by Spidervlad
Inconsistent color scheme? Thats called contrast from blue to green.As a judge, shouldn't you look closely at the signatures, atleast? Atleast look at the backgrounds or effects. You can't judge by using your guts and taking a quick look at both sigs.
They can judge any way they want and it's generally bad form to argue with the judge.
Frankly, I thought Melane's was better also, it fit the render better.
And your color scheme, comparing the background to the render, WAS inconsistent.