CW GG vs ROTS Sidious(Sabers only!) · Star Wars Versus Forum

vader11 Senior Member

CW GG vs ROTS Sidious(Sabers only!)

Utrigita Senior Member

movie analyse, Obi-wan defeats GG but he isn't strong enough according to Yoda to defeat Sidious, so it will look like this

Sidious>Obi Wan>GG Sidious wins.

Darth Brumbo S-N-I-P-E-R

That depends. All force users have to use the force to accurately use their sabers. Without being able to briefly see into the future to stop attacks, I think the General will win.
starwars

Utrigita Senior Member

I think that is included in the thread (sabers Only) refering to Sidious not lifting items and hurling lightnings after GG

Darth Brumbo S-N-I-P-E-R

ok then, it would be extremely close. I guess I agree with you: Sidious>Obi>General G

jollyjim311 Scruffy Nerf Herder

Sidious, with complete and utter ease.

darthsith19 Arm-Wrestler

movie analyse, Obi-wan defeats GG but he isn't strong enough according to Yoda to defeat Sidious, so it will look like this

Kenobi only beat Grievous so easily because of Soresu, and because that was ROTS Grievous and this is EU Grievous . And Yoda was speculating that Kenobi couldn't take Sidious, there's no way that Yoda would have known for sure, plus Sidious would only whoop Kenobi's ass because of the Force, in a saber duel Sidious would probably win but it'd be close.

That being said, Sidious will likely win but it won't be easy. Dooku admits in LOE that in a duel he is often "hard pressed to defeat the General." meaning Grievous is nearly as strong as Dooku is with a blade. Dooku is probably nearly as strong as Sidious is as well...

vader11 Senior Member

I can't decide who would win coz they are really close. Dooku has a lot of trouble to win GG. Dooku is probably eqaul or better than Sidious in saber fight. So, can't decide who would win. Also, this is CW GG! Not ROTS GG. GG still has a chance.

darthsith19 Arm-Wrestler

Originally posted by vader11
I can't decide who would win coz they are really close. Dooku has a lot of trouble to win GG. Dooku is probably eqaul or better than Sidious in saber fight. So, can't decide who would win. Also, this is CW GG! Not ROTS GG. GG still has a chance.

No, Sidious is above Dooku with a blade. Nick Gillard says that Sidious is a level 9 swordsman and Dooku is a level 8. And Dooku could neevr pwn Agen, Saesee and Kit like Sidious did. But it is close.

kamikz A.I.M Mercenary

I'll say once again, cause I never saw a reply, "When did Nick become a C-canon source?"

jollyjim311 Scruffy Nerf Herder

I'm also pretty sure this has been made before...

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

Sidious wins.

darthsith19 Arm-Wrestler

Originally posted by kamikz
I'll say once again, cause I never saw a reply, "When did Nick become a C-canon source?"

His word is more cannon then ours, I would think that it is C-Canon, I don't see why his word wouldn't be equal with the EU authors' words. And the characters do seem to be about how he rates them.

vader11 Senior Member

However, if Mace can defeat Sidious so qucikly, GG may have a chance to beat Sidious.(Remember, No force is allowed!)

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

But GG is no Mace Windu.

vader11 Senior Member

Originally posted by Count Makashi
But GG is no Mace Windu.

Mace has a lot of trouble fighting with GG in EU...just as Dooku...
If they can team up well, they would beat him...but I don't know if this can happen so I just say this fight would be close...

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

GG is very good but he got defeated by Kenobi and Mace is better then Kenobi, but yea, it would be close.

vader11 Senior Member

Originally posted by Count Makashi
GG is very good but he got defeated by Kenobi and Mace is better then Kenobi, but yea, it would be close.

This is CW GG, not ROTS GG! I doubt if CW Obiwan could beat CW GG...

Count Makashi Count Dookus number 1 fan

But Sidious can sense danger and their fore he can avoid CW GG lightsaber strikes because of this, GG cant do the same.

vader11 Senior Member

Originally posted by Count Makashi
But Sidious can sense danger and their fore he can avoid CW GG lightsaber strikes because of this, GG cant do the same.

But I doubt Sidious can be fast enough to avoid 5 sabers...