Originally posted by SouthernGirl814Your off topic one so don't even start on that. Also, it will end with that book.
If u8 don't like this topic stay out of it and I kinda wish she would write more books for Harry Potter just to see what happens afterwards u know?? but we all know thats not gonna happen and the story wouldnt end right phantom if Harry dies
If Rowling wants to kill off Harry, she'll do it well. It won't be written badly, it will be believable and it'll still make sense. It doesn't really matter what her fans think, Rowling's always written what she's wanted to, without regard to what anyone thinks. She'll finish off her story the way she wants to. People will still read it.
Originally posted by siriuswriter*Nods* Her book. No one elses.
If Rowling wants to kill off Harry, she'll do it well. It won't be written badly, it will be believable and it'll still make sense. It doesn't really matter what her fans think, Rowling's always written what she's wanted to, without regard to what anyone thinks. She'll finish off her story the way she wants to. People will still read it.
Originally posted by SouthernGirl814
I know that the 7th book is the last I'm sayin if Harry dies it screws everything up and the series don't end right
I always thought that both end situations would make logical sense. But I always thought that Harry Potter dying in the end makes a tad bit more sense then him being alive.
This being, because I have some absurd and rather farfetched theory. It goes something like this:
*takes deep breath*
Harry Potter is a Horcrux....
Yeah I said it. Now what would make me think this? Well for one thing, Dumbledore said that making Horcrux out of living beings is an odd thing to do. Harry Potter may in theory demonstrate these side effects, what with being able to feel what Voldemort feels, he's got a scar which causes him pain all the time and in the 5th book he was able to form see what Voldemort's snake was doing who coincidentally was a horcrux itself. Such a connection with the snake may have only been possible since they share a part of Voldemort's soul. Yes, I know a bit farfetched, and I know for a fact that this does not account for the prophecy either.
Originally posted by doan_mYes yes yes. There are threads on that. Stick to the topic.
I always thought that both end situations would make logical sense. But I always thought that Harry Potter dying in the end makes a tad bit more sense then him being alive.This being, because I have some absurd and rather farfetched theory. It goes something like this:
*takes deep breath*
Harry Potter is a Horcrux....
Yeah I said it. Now what would make me think this? Well for one thing, Dumbledore said that making Horcrux out of living beings is an odd thing to do. Harry Potter may in theory demonstrate these side effects, what with being able to feel what Voldemort feels, he's got a scar which causes him pain all the time and in the 5th book he was able to form see what Voldemort's snake was doing who coincidentally was a horcrux itself. Such a connection with the snake may have only been possible since they share a part of Voldemort's soul. Yes, I know a bit farfetched, and I know for a fact that this does not account for the prophecy either.
Originally posted by doan_m
Harry Potter is a Horcrux....
Yeah I said it. Now what would make me think this? Well for one thing, Dumbledore said that making Horcrux out of living beings is an odd thing to do. Harry Potter may in theory demonstrate these side effects, what with being able to feel what Voldemort feels, he's got a scar which causes him pain all the time and in the 5th book he was able to form see what Voldemort's snake was doing who coincidentally was a horcrux itself. Such a connection with the snake may have only been possible since they share a part of Voldemort's soul. Yes, I know a bit farfetched, and I know for a fact that this does not account for the prophecy either.
Um. The connection's also possible just because of the qualities of Voldemort that went into Harry because of the failed Avada Kedavra curse... that's how Dumbledore explained it, anyway. I tend to trust him when it comes to expository and background information.
What kind of story would it be if you knew that all the good guys would live and the bad ones would die? It would be boring, there would be no reason to read it because the enthusiasm of finding out what will happen would be gone.
MY personal opinion is, though i didn't like that she killed off certain characters, it was necissary to make the story that much better and am glad she wrote it the way she did.
If it upsets you so much to read a story that stay as realistic as possible, within the world of magic ( big oxymoron, i know ) then do not read the story. Plain and simple. Obviously you liked the way it went if you are still reading the books, so stop complaining.
Originally posted by TragicFairyTale
What kind of story would it be if you knew that all the good guys would live and the bad ones would die?
Yea it's gonna be weird that the books will be finished but they cant go one forever and the movies will still have 2 be made so it'll go on a little longer but I'm not sayin some of the good guys cant die but Harry iI don't think will die I don't think he is a horcrux like everyone thinks I think in the end his wand will be a horcrux and his scar will in the end disppear do u guys get what I'm sayin??
No,I haven't caught up on the discussion for the last few posts..But I think in my opinion,this topic is a bit pointless."She killed Harry's parents" ? Technically,SHE didn't kill anyone. She writes the books,you can't be mad at her for doing what she set out to do. If you're gunna have a come-apart,perhaps you shouldn't read book seven? People are going to continue dying,it's a war..not a pillow fight. In some books,they bring them back,but not in these. It gets dark,but if you [really] love it,you'll keep with it. I love the books,yes,there has been some disappointing material in there,but that's what makes them unique,you can't just call it a war and expect no one to get killed.I'm sure JK Isn't going to stop killing off characters for the people that don't like the way the books are being written. There's alot of people out there that feel the same way,I have to disagree,I myself,love how the books are turning out. I'll be terribly disappointed if Snape dies,but it's a book,and I'm still going to love them,nonetheless. There's no point worrying about it,you either read on,or not. =]
No offence.. 🙄 🙂