Black Adam vs Martian Manhunter

who wins?

Originally posted by jesserw21
who wins?

BA

Black Adam.

BA, definitely.

Interesting battle going on here...

I'm not quite sure if J'onn can resist magic and if BA is immune to telepathy. Those two should be the deciding factor.

However, one of J'onn's weakness is fire. So that should make things easier for BA.

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
However, one of J'onn's weakness is fire. So that should make things easier for BA.

He got over the fire weakness for the most part.

BA's immune to tp, right? Otherwise he's physically superior unless J'onn's clever as all hell with phasing.

Martian_Mind's going to have a fit....Black Adam wins

i think martian manhunter takes this. he would phase his hand in BA´s brain.

I am inclined to say MM here. Just cuz I love rooting for the underdog

is black adam really that superior to MM? i have serious doubts. MM can fight invisible, intagible, and can create clones, or i´m very mistaken or adam is being overrated.

Originally posted by Loot
is black adam really that superior to MM?

Martian Manhunter has stalemated Captain Marvel in a pure fist fight. BA is no better.

Originally posted by Validus
No.

Martian Manhunter has stalemated Captain Marvel in a pure fist fight. BA is no better.

CA was fighting mind control at the time.

Originally posted by jrodslam
CA was fighting mind control at the time.

Originally posted by Validus
That doesn't mean he wasn't hitting as hard. Just not fighting to the best of his ability.

In that case it just may mean that. Cap was trying to fight the mind control at the same time so he was holding back a deal.

I love J'onn, but 6.5/10 in a comic, Marvel or Teth all out would be written above J'onn.

They have to maintain that aura of power above others, since they're the classic rivals to Superman in power.

J'onn gets the word of mouth, but he doesn't get the hardcore showings.

Originally posted by UniOmni
I love J'onn, but 6.5/10 in a comic, Marvel or Teth all out would be written above J'onn.

They have to maintain that aura of power above others, since they're the classic rivals to Superman in power.

J'onn gets the word of mouth, but he doesn't get the hardcore showings.

Originally posted by Validus
lol So how come your panties get twisted when Avalon and I use that "in a comic" logic for Superman? 😛

Listen, lover of all things green and bright!

I admit, i used to get upset by that since it was hella hard to debate against.
It basically amounts to "Superman wins because he's Superman".

I DO think it's a hella weak debating tactic.

J'onn could likely win a majority going by KMC rules, since KMC tends to debate powersets alone.
I will never forget the Superman vs Magneto thread, where Avy said Superman will freeze Erik into a bubble and toss him into the sun............
Superman doesn't do that, but he could.

Perfect example of KMC debate tactics.

SHC has ruined me, since they go by in character fights and comparisons.

And lest you forget, you once got into a heated debate with Avy, in some DD vs MM thread i made, and Avy took the in comic comparison route, and you said that it doesn't matter since in the forum, he's not compounded by jobbing to the S shield.

KMC = MM 6-7/10

Comic = Teth 6.5/10

Happy now, closet hulk fanboy?!

Manhunter could win if he was very creative with his intangibility, but I don't really think he would win.

Black Adam is an angry badass...BUT
...Martian Manhunter is also an angry badass in current continuity.

Both were owned by SBP.

MM did better, even though both were pwned.

MM wins.... how's that for comic logic????