Originally posted by Tempe Brennan
I beg to differ, she has one of the best voices I have ever heard. I never imagined her as a soul singer - even when I bought her album I expected her music to be pop at best. I was so surprised when I discover this wonderful soul music
Whatever she is singing in that overly affected and unnatural stage school voice is not soul music thats for damn shizzle, she has one of the best voices you have ever heard?, have you heard Ella Fitzgerald, Bessie Smith, Billie Holliday or Nina Simone?, these are the people she is emulating/parodying, these are the people whose legacy is being tarnished by this hack. She sings like she has a mouthful of sick and she probably does. 😛
Originally posted by papabeard
Whatever she is singing in that overly affected and unnatural stage school voice is not soul music thats for damn shizzle, she has one of the best voices you have ever heard?, have you heard Ella Fitzgerald, Bessie Smith, Billie Holliday or Nina Simone?, these are the people she is emulating/parodying, these are the people whose legacy is being tarnished by this hack. She sings like she has a mouthful of sick and she probably does. 😛
If you feel those greats are being tarnished by Winehouse, then you truly do not appreciate greatness at all. She doesn't have the ability to ruin anyone else's legacy.
-AC
Originally posted by papabeard
have you heard Ella Fitzgerald, Bessie Smith, Billie Holliday or Nina Simone?, these are the people she is emulating/parodying, these are the people whose legacy is being tarnished by this hack. She sings like she has a mouthful of sick and she probably does. 😛
I have heard Ella Fitzgerald, and I actually think she's be proud to have someone like Winehouse emulate her.
Have you even listened to her album 'Back To Black'? There are some brilliant songs on that album, I kid you not.
Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
If you feel those greats are being tarnished by Winehouse, then you truly do not appreciate greatness at all. She doesn't have the ability to ruin anyone else's legacy.-AC
Tarnished in the minds of fools, who cannot differentiate between true genius and mediocrity.
Well no, you can't blame Amy Winehouse for something she isn't doing.
She isn't tarnishing anyone's legacy, you cannot get upset because idiots perceive her as something she may not be.
Furthermore, your whole argument is that she is tarnishing the great legacy of Nina Simone et al in the minds of morons, right? Well, if you have to sit there and point those morons in the direction of these legends, then chances are that they didn't even know them in the first place.
It's just stupid. Let it go.
-AC