Originally posted by ADarksideJediNo. There are signs that point to him living, and signs that point to him dying. I really don't care either way, because it's a book, but I just think writing 7 books, only to have the main character die at the end is some huge anticlimax. It's not exactly the best thing she could do. I'd rather have Cliche than anticlimax.
I face that fact he is not coming back along time ago.But still we do know harry is going to die in this one right?All in argeement?jm
Originally posted by fozzy2k5Impossible. The prophecy states that the only one who can rival Voldemort is Harry. Assuming the prophecy is right, if Harry were to die, or kill himself, Voldemort would still be alive. This would mean that Voldemort wouldn't be killed, and Harry and the Order would be defeated.
i agree with jm , harry is going to die because he will somehow have to kill himself to kill voldemort
Harry also cannot be a Horcrux. Creating a Horcrux takes complicated magic. We don't know if it's a spell, or a potion, or maybe some type of emotion bond combined with a potion and a spell. We don't know the exact details. However, we do know that it's impossible for Harry to be a Horcrux, because he was never in the vicinity of Voldemort long enough for him to have made a Horcrux out of him, sparing the graveyard.
However,Harry would've noticed if part of Voldemort's soul was branded inside of him during Goblet. Also, Crazy V probably wouldn't make a Horcrux in front of anybody, regardless of their loyalty towards him.
So, in conclusion, Harry probably won't die, and he's not a Horcrux.
Originally posted by ~Pielover~I wont go on either side of the whole horcrux thing till I see details on what happened at Godric's Hollow. I wanna see what spell Voldemort used. (Just because it was green doesn't making it the killing curse.)
Impossible. The prophecy states that the only one who can rival Voldemort is Harry. Assuming the prophecy is right, if Harry were to die, or kill himself, Voldemort would still be alive. This would mean that Voldemort wouldn't be killed, and Harry and the Order would be defeated.Harry also cannot be a Horcrux. Creating a Horcrux takes complicated magic. We don't know if it's a spell, or a potion, or maybe some type of emotion bond combined with a potion and a spell. We don't know the exact details. However, we do know that it's impossible for Harry to be a Horcrux, because he was never in the vicinity of Voldemort long enough for him to have made a Horcrux out of him, sparing the graveyard.
However,Harry would've noticed if part of Voldemort's soul was branded inside of him during Goblet. Also, Crazy V probably wouldn't make a Horcrux in front of anybody, regardless of their loyalty towards him.
So, in conclusion, Harry probably won't die, and he's not a Horcrux.
Harry does not have to kill himself to kill the dark lord but it is possible that he will die after kililng Voldemort.Also to write seven books and to h ave the main chactor die at the end of the last book makes sence to me.
Alot of writters attend to do that.It is not un normal for the writter to kill the hero.I would not care if she did or not.Harry to me is not one of my favorites I go for the bad guys in books.No reason!jm
Originally posted by ADarksideJediNever become a writer. Your grammar is horrible.
Harry does not have to kill himself to kill the dark lord but it is possible that he will die after kililng Voldemort.Also to write seven books and to h ave the main chactor die at the end of the last book makes sence to me.
Alot of writters attend to do that.It is not un normal for the writter to kill the hero.I would not care if she did or not.Harry to me is not one of my favorites I go for the bad guys in books.No reason!jm
Originally posted by ~Pielover~
Impossible. The prophecy states that the only one who can rival Voldemort is Harry. Assuming the prophecy is right, if Harry were to die, or kill himself, Voldemort would still be alive. This would mean that Voldemort wouldn't be killed, and Harry and the Order would be defeated.Harry also cannot be a Horcrux. Creating a Horcrux takes complicated magic. We don't know if it's a spell, or a potion, or maybe some type of emotion bond combined with a potion and a spell. We don't know the exact details. However, we do know that it's impossible for Harry to be a Horcrux, because he was never in the vicinity of Voldemort long enough for him to have made a Horcrux out of him, sparing the graveyard.
However,Harry would've noticed if part of Voldemort's soul was branded inside of him during Goblet. Also, Crazy V probably wouldn't make a Horcrux in front of anybody, regardless of their loyalty towards him.
So, in conclusion, Harry probably won't die, and he's not a Horcrux.
Yes But What If The Prophercy Was Wrong !!
Okey, first of all. JM, your speling sucks. Second of all, chances of Harry being the last Horcrux seem impossible to me.
Think of it! Voldemort killed Lily, James and then wanted to place a Horcrux in the exact same person who has the biggest chance of killing him? Remember, that once the spell backfired on Voldemort he almost died, and remained only as simple spirit or ghost.
Doing so, Voldemort put himself at risk of being competely killed. Anyone could have killed him at such a weak word. Adding to that, in Slughorn's memory we have also seen that in order for a Horcrux to be put into an object, then the caster has to say a special spell. Most of our evidence state that Voldemort used the Avada Kadavra spell on Harry. Thus his name as the only boy who has ever survived the killing spell.
And anyway, wasn't there a huge story about how J.K.Rowling finished the book, but then some critic or something who was important or something told Rowling that she shouldn't make a mistake such as that? And people think that the mistake that the critic was pointing at is that she killed someone important.
Originally posted by ~Pielover~
With...?
Originally posted by fozzy2k5
Yes But What If The Prophercy Was Wrong !!