Darthgoober's Amalgam Tourney discussion thread

Originally posted by Scoobless
Headshots?

Col. America got his head cut in half and it didn't slow him down ... nothing has killed the Zombies yet.

Originally posted by Scoobless
Col. America got his head cut in half and it didn't slow him down ... nothing has killed the Zombies yet.

No , but when Red Skull tore his brains out he died.

So Far....

King Kandy
Martian_mind
TricksterPriest
Entity
Joey Stacks
Blair Wind
Roldz
Scoobless
Newjak
Ethereal
Devil Lance
leonidas

Draft #1:

1.Yellowjacket (Hank Pym)
2.Hawkman
3.Northstar
4.SPIRAL
5.Tony Stark
6.Warlock(New Mutants)
7.Vision
8.Speedfreak
9.Nightshade(awaiting repick)
10.Abomination
11.Karate Kid
12.Spartan

Draft #2

(1)Indigo (probably getting banned)
(2)Venom
(3)The Spot
(4)Sabertooth
(5)Moonstone II
(6)Cosmic King
(7)Umbra
(8)Colossus
(9).Selene
(10)Zxaxz (may be banned)

There's somebody from round one who really shouldn't be allowed...

EDIT: Unless it's classic.

Who?

If it's Northstar then it's the old version - already been covered.

Not sure why Abomination is still there though.

Originally posted by Scoobless
Not sure why Abomination is still there though.

Goober ruled that Abom's losing record, coupled with his strength not being over Namor in water, is enough to let him in.

Originally posted by Scoobless
If it's Northstar then it's the old version - already been covered.

Namor underwater eh? That strength level is a little >> IM ... but ok, good to know.

Yeah, he seems to be using most of the old caps from the failed tournament.

Oh, ok, that explains some stuff then.

🙂

So Far....

Entity
Scoobless
Blair Wind
leonidas
Roldz
Devil Lance
Newjak
Martian_mind
King Kandy
Ethereal
TricksterPriest
Joey Stacks

Draft #1:

1.Hank Pym
2.Hawkman
3.Northstar
4.SPIRAL
5.Tony Stark
6.Warlock
7.Vision
8.Speedfreak
9.Nightshade
10.Abomination
11.Karate Kid
12.Spartan

Draft #2

(1)Indigo
(2)Venom
(3)The Spot
(4)Sabertooth
(5)Moonstone II
(6)Cosmic King
(7)Umbra
(8)Colossus
(9).Selene
(10)Zxaxz

So who does everyone think is the top 3 best and worse picks so far? 😕

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
Yeah, he seems to be using most of the old caps from the failed tournament.

Alright now with those things out of the way, I'm going to need some more input from my participants and judges in regards to several of the picks. I'd have you all PM your opinions to me, but the way my inbox has been blowing up as of late, I'm likely to lose track of some of them. Because of that, I'll ask anyone who has a case to make AGAINST a character to post it, and only PM me if it's you defending your character and your trying to keep the fact a secret.

1.Warlock- It's been brought to my attention that Warlock MAY be to powerful overall to allow, or at the very least his "killability" may be somewhere along the lines of Sandman or Hydroman. So I'm going to need some instance that show either of these things to be either true or untrue.

2.Indigo- I don't know a lot about the girl, but I can't ban her just because she's a version of Braniac. I know that she's got at least one high showing, but how is she portrayed on average? Many people are team busters on occasion(just look at Wolverine and Spiderman), but how many times has she trounced Iron Man level characters in a one on one fight? If you guys have actual proof that she's more powerful, that's fine. But I haven't seen anything personally that would place her over the caps, so if you have an instance just post it(preferably a scan), along with any extenuating circumstances that where present so I can accurately judge the feat.

3. Cosmic King- I know literally NOTHING about this guy, so ANY scans that show the range of his abilities would be appreciated.

4. Selene- I'm about ready to ban her after reading some of the stuff she's accomplished, I'm really just looking for everyone's opinion on her before I do so.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Alright now with those things out of the way, I'm going to need some more input from my participants and judges in regards to several of the picks. I'd have you all PM your opinions to me, but the way my inbox has been blowing up as of late, I'm likely to lose track of some of them. Because of that, I'll ask anyone who has a case to make AGAINST a character to post it, and only PM me if it's you defending your character and your trying to keep the fact a secret.

1.Warlock- It's been brought to my attention that Warlock MAY be to powerful overall to allow, or at the very least his "killability" may be somewhere along the lines of Sandman or Hydroman. So I'm going to need some instance that show either of these things to be either true or untrue.

2.Indigo- I don't know a lot about the girl, but I can't ban her just because she's a version of Braniac. I know that she's got at least one high showing, but how is she portrayed on average? Many people are team busters on occasion(just look at Wolverine and Spiderman), but how many times has she trounced Iron Man level characters in a one on one fight? If you guys have actual proof that she's more powerful, that's fine. But I haven't seen anything personally that would place her over the caps, so if you have an instance just post it(preferably a scan), along with any extenuating circumstances that where present so I can accurately judge the feat.

3. Cosmic King- I know literally NOTHING about this guy, so ANY scans that show the range of his abilities would be appreciated.

4. Selene- I'm about ready to ban her after reading some of the stuff she's accomplished, I'm really just looking for everyone's opinion on her before I do so.

Cosmic Kings only power is transmutation
http://rds.yahoo.com/_ylt=A9ibyiEYLixGM9EA53ejzbkF;_ylu=X3oDMTA4NDgyNWN0BHNlYwNwcm9m/SIG=131kjr43g/EXP=1177386904/**http%3A//www.supermanartists.comics.org/superwhoswho/cosmicking-superman147.JPG

Originally posted by Devil Lance
Cosmic Kings only power is transmutation
http://rds.yahoo.com/_ylt=A9ibyiEYLixGM9EA53ejzbkF;_ylu=X3oDMTA4NDgyNWN0BHNlYwNwcm9m/SIG=131kjr43g/EXP=1177386904/**http%3A//www.supermanartists.comics.org/superwhoswho/cosmicking-superman147.JPG

Ban cosmic King, transmutation is finicky and causes problems to crop up, Selene on the overhand get's an 'insta-ban' due to her life-drain ability.

I was told to take Eth's place.