KMC Comic Book Tiers

Started by B.A485 pages

Originally posted by batdude123
Lawlz. 🙂
No need to laugh. 🙄

I take back my statement anyway.

Low herald for sure. ✅

Originally posted by DigiMark007
😂

Yeah, at first KMC "borrowed" 3-4 threads from SHC, but anymore they do the same to us because ours is much larger. I don't mind, as long as they give credit and post the original link.

Its just like Marvel and D.C. Everyone takes from everyone else. But we do have a pretty good respect forum but not as organized as yours. Good job on it BTW. 👆

Terrax to low. For: 3 (Bat, llag, TP) Against: 6 (bran, Strength, Rash, Newjack, Smurph, Soljer)
Ravenous to low. For: 2 (llag, TP) Against: 4 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash)
Darkseid to Trans. For: 7 (Bran, Soljer, Quan, Val, Priest, Strength, Goober) Against: 9 (fatnude, ass, T-pain, nvr, Spauld, Crest, llag, Newjack, Mike)

---

Also:

Originally posted by MightyEInherjar
I vote to add Kurse to High Herald, if not higher.

Originally posted by Bransolute
Terrax to low. For: 3 (Bat, llag, TP) Against: 6 (bran, Strength, Rash, Newjack, Smurph, Soljer)
Ravenous to low. For: 2 (llag, TP) Against: 4 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash)
Darkseid to Trans. For: 7 (Bran, Soljer, Quan, Val, Priest, Strength, Goober) Against: 9 (fatnude, ass, T-pain, nvr, Spauld, Crest, llag, Newjack, Mike)

---

Also:

Where are the people voting for Ravenous against low putting him? 😕

Mid Herald

Originally posted by Val
Mid Herald
Ah.

He got beaten by Ronan at one point but won another.

General statement:

Once enough votes are gathered and a motion seems to be vetoed, we can eliminate it. Terrax, for example, is 6-3 in favor of "nay". Even if it evens itself out, we still need a general consensus. So it's pretty much defeated at this point. Similarly, if it were the other way around, we'd be about what we need to make the switch.

But as always, good job keeping track of votes.

And I'll vote for Ravenous to Low (so "for"😉. He never really showed me anything, and is a limited character.

Ravenous for low.

Brought an entire army with him to face down Terrax and Air Walker. Terrax and Air Walker for petes sake. Barely got the better of a weakened Firelord. Tooled by Surfer twice.

It's made pretty obvious he isn't on par with a Galactus herald despite his boasting. He's durable which is the only thing I see from him that's herald level.

Ravenous to low. For: 4 (llag, TP, Digi, Val) Against: 4 (bran, Smurph, Soljer, Rash)
Darkseid to Trans. For: 7 (Bran, Soljer, Quan, Val, Priest, Strength, Goober) Against: 9 (fatnude, ass, T-pain, nvr, Spauld, Crest, llag, Newjack, Mike)
Kurse to high herald. For: 1 (Mighty) Against: 0

Terrax stays at mid.

---
Also, I don't really agree with Kurse going there, and the against votes don't describe where to go, so should there be another vote that would put Kurse at mid or something (which should happen to Rav as well)?

I don't even know what the fuck you just said.

Should we have a separate vote to put Kurse or Ravenous at mid (or wherever), or should we just put the people that think he should be at mid (or wherever) in the disagree section of the original vote?

That's what Bran said.

If 'tomorrow' happens - I'm definitely changing my vote for Sentry....

Originally posted by Soljer
If 'tomorrow' happens - I'm definitely changing my vote for Sentry....

Indeed.

For people that we're placing for the first time: Once voting dies down, if there isn't a consensus, go with the lower of the two since it's more conservative. This goes for anyone.

Originally posted by Bransolute
[B)
Also, I don't really agree with Kurse going there, and the against votes don't describe where to go, so should there be another vote that would put Kurse at mid or something (which should happen to Rav as well)? [/B]

It's times like this I really wish I had a scanner, because I have pretty much all of Kurse's showings, and there's nothing really to support him being put at any lower than High or at least Mid Herald.

I mean, the guy was trashing half of Asgard trying to get to Baldr like they weren't even there...

Originally posted by MightyEInherjar
It's times like this I really wish I had a scanner, because I have pretty much all of Kurse's showings, and there's nothing really to support him being put at any lower than High or at least Mid Herald.

I mean, the guy was trashing half of Asgard trying to get to Baldr like they weren't even there...

Actually...now that I look at all who's in the "Mid Herald" tier, I suppose that's actually a good spot for him. Being along side Morg, Lobo, etc sits right with me.

Go ahead and change my vote to "Mid" for now.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Now you know how your hypothetical situation looks to me.

Is that why you thought I said good God?

Where is Lobo again?

Mid? Shouldn't he be high?

Anyway just finished the Apollo thread.

Low herald it is.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=9799179#post9799179

Lobo barely deserves mid as is.

Captain Mar-vell > Mighty Avengers.

Mar-Vell to high herald.